4 Lessons The Military Learned In The Wake Of Hurricane Katrina

Community
U.S. Air Force photo by Staff Sgt. Jacob N. Bailey

Ten years ago this week, Hurricane Katrina swept through the Gulf states, killing over 1,200 people, leaving thousands more homeless, and causing over $100 billion in damage — one of the worst natural disasters to befall the United States. Nearly 70,000 troops — active duty, Reserve, and National Guard — would eventually become involved in relief efforts, the largest effort in U.S. history, according to a study commissioned by the U.S. Army Combat Studies Institute.


I know because I was there with about 5,000 paratroopers of the U.S. Army’s 82nd Airborne Division.

Hurricane Katrina was a watershed event, leading to drastic reforms in the way the U.S. government responds to disasters. For the military, however, here were just four lessons that proved their worth not just in Katrina, but in future relief efforts.

1. “Go Unclassified Early.”

The Pentagon has a veritable alphabet soup of computer networks, but most of them are useless for sharing information with first responders and local government officials. That’s a lesson I learned in my first days in New Orleans, when Google Earth was more useful than the military’s flight planning software, FalconView.

That lesson hasn’t been lost in subsequent disaster relief efforts. When the 82nd Airborne 325th Airborne Infantry Regiment headed to Haiti following massive earthquakes in 2010, one Army major forced his entire brigade to work on unclassified networks to better share information with civilian disaster-relief agencies.  

The lesson hasn’t been lost on the Army’s leadership either. Military and civilian responders often crowdsource their efforts, collaborating with Google products. There’s an added bonus: The Army and volunteer-relief services like Team Rubicon have found commercial software, such as Palantir, more effective than some of the military’s high-end programs.

2. Support, support, support.

Once the storm clouds finally passed, government officials seemed to spend more time pointing fingers than helping the people of the Gulf Coast. Of course, there was plenty of blame to be found among federal, state, and local officials. It certainly didn’t help that New Orleans is one of the most corrupt cities in America, with former mayor Ray Nagin currently serving a 10-year prison sentence for fraud, bribery, and money laundering.

The only organization that seemed to offer hope was the military. As the waters began to recede in New Orleans’ Ninth Ward, emergency responders were horrified to learn another hurricane, Rita, was barreling towards Louisiana. Lt. Gen. Russel Honoré, who by then had become the most trustworthy face in Louisiana amid the chaos, began to position the military just along the edge of the storm, ready to swoop in once Rita cleared. During a press conference, however, reporters pressed Honoré to blame New Orleans officials for the poor state of affairs in Katrina’s wake. Honoré delivered perhaps the most memorable line of the entire Katrina affair, berating reporters for focusing on the last storm instead of preparing for the next storm: “Don’t get stuck on stupid,” he said.

Even with over one-hundred thousand service members in Iraq and Afghanistan, the U.S. military still mustered tens of thousands of troops in just a few weeks. They restored power, lifted stranded residents from rooftops, and paddled through stagnant muck searching for survivors.

Honoré’s no-nonsense attitude, coupled with the military’s uncanny penchant for problem-solving, may have led some to believe the military was really in charge of cleaning up New Orleans.  

But it wasn’t. Nor should it have been.

It’s tempting for the military to want to take the lead during a disaster; we’re so used to leading nation-building efforts abroad, it’s become second nature. But federal troops are only on hand to help local government get back on its feet; and even then, only in a supporting role, never in the lead.  

3. Go Guard.

According to the Army’s Combat Studies Institute, over 46,000 guardsmen were active in Louisiana and Mississippi in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, outnumbering federal troops more than 2-to-1 and exceeding the active force’s helicopter contribution.  

Whereas federal assistance generally arrives in a matter of days, the National Guard can respond in just a few hours. Indeed, the National Guard is the state’s professional, go-to force for disaster relief, whether it be floods, hurricanes, wildfires, or riots. National Guardsmen have a vested interest in helping communities prepare, survive, and recover from disasters because they, too, are part of the community.

That said, each state needs a guard force properly trained and equipped to respond to contingencies both at home and abroad. (And yes, that means Black Hawks and Chinooks, not Apaches.)   

4. Practice, practice, practice.  

As they say in the business, a disaster isn’t the time to exchange business cards. Government officials learned that lesson painfully during Hurricane Katrina, where massive communication breakdowns hampered relief efforts.

Responders at all levels of government must train for the next complex disaster. U.S. Army North, the lead agency for providing defense support for civil authorities, does just that every year during an exercise known as Vibrant Response, which simulates the effects of a 10-kiloton nuclear blast in a major American city. Training at the Muscatatuck Urban Training Center in rural Indiana, the doomsday scenario borrows heavily from the chaos that followed Hurricane Katrina.

The Army hires dozens of actors to recreate the absolute bedlam of a major catastrophe, fitting for an exercise that takes place on the grounds of an old mental asylum. Sparing no expense, the massive urban training center also features a small zoo, perhaps inspired by events during the Katrina aftermath, where apex predators loose at the New Orleans zoo merely added to the rescuers’ headaches. Better to face the difficult situations in training than to encounter them for the first time during a real disaster.

Comedian Steve Carell will be starring in an upcoming Netflix show about the new Space Force that's being described as a "workplace comedy."

Yeah, that's right. The Office, but in freaking space.

Read More Show Less
George Washington takes command of the Continental army. (Mount Vernon via Smithsonian)

The First Conspiracy: The Secret Plot to Kill George Washington by Brad Meltzer and Josh Mensch; Flatiron Books (413 pages, $29.99)

———

New York City has seen dark times, but in the spring and early summer of 1776 the outlook was especially grim. The Revolutionary War was in its early, chaotic days, the British fleet sailed en masse toward the city, and in a desperate defensive measure, General George Washington ordered thousands of his Continental troops into lower Manhattan. Almost a third of the city's citizens fled, and Washington's filthy, untrained and undisciplined soldiers quartered themselves in the elegant houses left behind. They were hungry, cold and scared, and they numbed their fear with drink, gambling and prostitutes. They were about to face the greatest military force in the world, outgunned and outmanned, fighting for a country that hadn't been created yet.

In hindsight, America's victory against the British seems like one of history's inevitabilities, but in the beginning it was anything but. And had a small group of pro-British conspirators had their way, the Glorious Cause might have lost its essential leader — George Washington — to imprisonment, execution or assassination.

Read More Show Less
Sen. Jack Reed, D-R.I., left, and Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., center, members of the Senate Armed Services Committee, are disagreeing with President Donald Trump's sudden decision to pull all 2,000 U.S. troops out of Syria, during a news conference at the Capitol in Washington, Thursday, Dec. 20, 2018. (Associated Press/J. Scott Applewhite)

Sen. Lindsey Graham essentially laid the deaths of the unknown number of U.S. soldiers killed in a suicide bombing in Manbij, Syria, on Wednesday at the feet of President Donald Trump during a hearing on Capitol Hill, Bloomberg News reports.

Read More Show Less
Soldiers, family and community gathered in Morehead City to render honors and witness the transfer and memorial of U.S. Army Sgt James Slape Nov. 9-11, 2018. Slape will hold a temporary resting place in Morehead City before ultimately moving to Arlington Cemetery. Slape supported Operations Resolute Support and Freedom Sentinel in Afghanistan. (U.S. Army National Guard Photo by Staff Sgt Leticia Samuels, North Carolina National Guard)

An ISIS suicide bomber killed and wounded an unknown number of American soldiers in Manbij, Syria, on Wednesday.

Read More Show Less