4 Reasons Navy–Air Force Is A Better Football Rivalry Than Army–Navy

news

Navy and Air Force meet on the gridiron in Annapolis, Maryland, Saturday, Oct. 3, in what has become a great and competitive college football rivalry. This contest is the first game in the quest to win the Commander-in-Chief’s Trophy, the triangular football series between the three major service academy teams: the U.S. Military Academy Black Knights, the U.S. Naval Academy Midshipmen, and the U.S. Air Force Academy Falcons. The winning team of the series is invited to the White House to meet the president and has bragging rights among the service academies for the next year.


Most people know about the pageantry and tradition of the ArmyNavy game, which recently has not been much of a rivalry with Navy currently owning a 13-game winning streak in the storied series. Unfortunately, the current team’s records (Navy 3-0; Army 1-3) predict that Navy’s victory streak will not end anytime soon.  

While conventional wisdom says the ArmyNavy game is here to stay as the premier service academy football rivalry, here are four reasons why the Air Force Falcons vs. Navy Midshipmen game is probably a better overall contest and rivalry.

1. The Air Force vs. Navy game is more competitive.

Navy running back Dishan Romine, left, is dragged down after a short gain by Air Force defensive backs Christian Spears, center, and Jamal Byrd in the first quarter of an NCAA college football game at Air Force Academy, Colorado, Oct. 4, 2014.AP photo by David Zalubowski

During Navy’s 13-year winning streak in the ArmyNavy series, the Midshipmen have outscored the Black Knights 417 to 142. Most math majors (even those from Army) would agree those two numbers are not even close.

Conversely, over the same 13-year span from 2003 to 2014, Air Force and Navy have been more even in total scoring: Navy with 300 to Air Force with 257. From 20032011, the average margin of victory was a mere five points, even though Navy won seven of the nine contests.  

2. There is no love lost between the two teams.

Navy head coach Ken Niumatalolo, right, meets with Air Force head coach Troy Calhoun, left, after an NCAA football game, Oct. 5, 2013.AP photo by Nick Wass

Unlike Army and Navy, no matter how much Navy and Air Force express a mutual admiration publicly, the two teams don’t really like each other. It’s been that way for a while.

In 2006, after the Midshipmen’s fourth straight victory over the Falcons, then-Navy coach Paul Johnson came out of the locker room with a chip on his shoulder saying, “I'm proud to be the coach of one of the luckiest teams in America. We've been lucky four years in a row, any way you want to spin it."  

Evidently, Johnson was tired of hearing in the press that luck, and not his team’s execution, was the determining factor for Navy’s success against Air Force. Then-Air Force coach Fisher DeBerry denied making the “lucky” comments.

"He didn't hear it from our football team," DeBerry said.

In 2011, Air Force won a wild overtime affair 35-34 that included a controversial taunting penalty by Navy. Navy’s then-quarterback Kriss Proctor ran for a one-yard touchdown to open the overtime, but was penalized for unsportsmanlike conduct after getting in an Air Force defender’s face. The resultant penalty forced Navy into a long conversion attempt from 35 yards out that was blocked by the Falcons. Air Force scored a touchdown on the ensuing possession and converted the point to defeat the Midshipmen on their home turf for the first time since 2002.

Even the Commander-in-Chief’s Trophy is not immune to the animosity between the two teams. In 2012, when Air Force had already lost to both Navy and Army, the trophy was delivered from Colorado Springs to the ArmyNavy game for it to be awarded to the winner of that contest.  

When the trophy arrived, there were questions about the care and state of disrepair the trophy appeared to be in, particularly to the Navy portion of the trophy. During its two years at Air Force, somehow Bill the Goat, the Navy mascot, acquired a crutch to prop him up on the trophy, sparking a mild outcry among the Midshipmen faithful.  

Most recently, last year’s contest saw four personal fouls committed in the first half, including a targeting call that ejected Air Force’s senior defensive back Justin Decoud for helmet-to-helmet contact against Navy quarterback Keenan Reynolds.   

3. The quality of team both teams is unmatched.

Navy quarterback Keenan Reynolds (19) weaves his way around Air Force defensive back Gavin McHenry, right, Joey Nichol (49) and Reggie Barnes, left, during the second half of an NCAA football game, Oct. 5, 2013.AP photo by Nick Wass

Since 2007, Air Force and Navy have combined for 14 bowl appearances with each team only missing one year when they did not qualify for a bowl. Army has been to one bowl in that same time span.

The Falcons are coming off a 10-3 season in 2014 where they defeated perennial powerhouse Boise State, won the Commander-in-Chief’s Trophy, and defeated Western Michigan in a bowl game. This year, Air Force put up a valiant fight against then-No. 4 Michigan State (now No. 4), losing 35-21 and has started the season at a respectable 2-1.

Navy is 3-0 and is receiving votes in both The Associated Press and USA Today/Coaches polls this week. The current team has a true superstar in record-setting quarterback Keenan Reynolds. Reynolds is poised to set the record for most career-rushing touchdowns in the NCAA history. He is currently tied for second in NCAA history among all players for rushing touchdowns, just four behind record-holder Montee Ball of Wisconsin. He currently has 24 wins as the Navy starting quarterback, more than 1963 Heisman trophy winner and Navy quarterback Roger Staubach.

Comparably, Army is currently 1-3 and lost to Fordham for the first time since 1891 in early September. The Black Knights have only had one winning season since 1997.

4. Very little can compare to real flyovers.

U.S. Navy photo by Petty Officer 1st Class Michael Lindsey

It’s pretty hard to impressively roll a lumbering M1 Abrams tank through the stadium and not crush the field of play, so the tank option probably does not get a nod for best pre-game pomp and circumstance. Even the Army AH-64 Apache helicopter, an impressive attack gunship, doesn’t quite hold a candle to an Air Force or Navy flyover. The Apache has a top speed of around 150 mph, making it slower than the new Corvette Stingray.

With Air Force and Navy, you always get a quality flyover. Last year’s game at Colorado Springs featured two F-22 Raptors. This year’s game will feature four Super Hornets from Naval Air Station Oceana.  

As every fighter pilot knows, “Speed is life.” Speed wins in football, flyovers, and quite possibly rivalries.

AP photo by David Zalubowski
(AP Photo/South Bend Tribune, Greg Swiercz)

Your humble Pentagon correspondent has never been one of the "cool kids" in the world of Washington media, and never has that been more evident than in my failed attempts to interview Navy veteran Pete Buttigieg, mayor of South Bend, Indiana, and one of the roughly 50,000 Democrats running for president.

To the media, Buttigieg is so hot right now that he could melt the stealth coating off an F-35 – which is actually not as hard as it sounds. He is fluent in more forms of communication than C-3PO – in April, he offered his condolences to the French people for the Notre Dame fire in perfect French. He's had no problem getting media coverage from all sorts of media outlets, including National Public Radio, the New York Times, or even Fox News.

Your intrepid Pentagon correspondent was briefly on Mayor Pete's schedule, when his director of campaign operations Max Harris set up an interview for Feb. 26. But less than an hour later, Harris emailed back to say he might have to reschedule the interview due to scheduling conflicts.

Four months of silence followed. (To be fair, his campaign manager Lis Smith did confirm in March that Buttigieg had formed an exploratory committee to run for president.)

Read More Show Less
Department of Veterans Affairs photo via Military.com

Editor's Note: This article by Richard Sisk originally appeared on Military.com a leading source of news for the military and veteran community.

The union representing 260,000 Department of Veterans Affairs employees recently won a "cease and desist" arbitration ruling against the department's posting of lengthy lists of firings, suspensions and other disciplinary actions in violation of the Privacy Act.

Read More Show Less
ISNA/Handout via REUTERS

The two oil tankers crippled in attacks in the Gulf of Oman last week that Washington and Riyadh have blamed on Iran are being assessed off the coast off the United Arab Emirates before their cargos are unloaded, the ships' operators said on Sunday.

Read More Show Less
U.S. Army/Spc. Rashene Mincy

For retired Sgt 1st Class Confessor Bermudez Jr., Pvt. Dorian Bermudez and Capt. Timothy Peters, watching their fathers' military service has helped inspire their own military careers.

For Father's Day, each took time to reflect on what stood out to them during their fathers' careers and how their fathers have supported them as they, too, have joined the military.

Read More Show Less
U.S. Air Force/Tech. Sgt. Robert Cloys

A U.S. military drone was shot down over Yemen on June 6, and just a week later, another MQ-9 Reaper was targeted over the Gulf of Oman on June 13, according to a U.S. Central Command statement.

Read More Show Less