Get Task & Purpose in your inbox
4 Things Television’s Top Writer Can Teach Us About Military Leadership
Editor’s Note: This article has been modified from its original version, which was published on “Beyond the Objective,” a blog by Doctrine Man.
Note on suspension of disbelief: This quick piece is not intended to address the political preferences inherent in the television content discussed below. I left my political biases at the door, and I hope you can do the same.
I was recently drawn into the television show “The Newsroom,” a fictional series created by Aaron Sorkin based around the tensions and choices made when covering the news (at least from the perspective of a cable news channel). What struck me about this show was not the sexual drama (everyone is sleeping with or dating everyone else at some point), the shifting existential crises of the main characters in every show, or even the political commentary inherent in the message of each show . The overall theme of the show is the challenge of treading the fine line between journalistic responsibility and making money for parent corporations to remain on the air. Instead, I was struck that every show contained a healthy dose of mentorship, and not the feel-good, “I’m a commander and I just gave great career advice to a subordinate in a scheduled counseling” kind of way.
The beauty of any Sorkin television drama — something I didn’t realize until I had this epiphany about “The Newsroom” and went back to look at his other shows like “The West Wing” and “Sports Night ” — is his coverage of the varied dynamics of mentorship: ambition, loyalty, frustration, intellectual engagement, self-identification, discipline, flexibility, fear for the success of a cause, desire to leave your job/profession better than you found it, personal investment in others, self-sacrifice, and even pride.
No matter what sanitized version of mentorship the military vomits into its doctrine, or even worse, the personnel technocrats warp into an "official” program, mentorship is a relationship. It is an in-depth, long-term personal connection between two people who have an asymmetry in either knowledge or skills — rank matters not. Mentorship only occurs if there’s a personal spark between two people ; both the mentor and the protege have to believe the other is worth spending time on and with.
In “The Newsroom,” the more experienced leaders in the organization are constantly balancing the conflicting drivers of mentorship. They attempt to achieve their selfish visions for themselves and their profession (I particularly appreciate the humble and arrogant aspects of the main character’s “mission to civilize” and constant allusions to Don Quixote), pushing those around them, failing as role models, sometimes taking responsibility for others’ actions, making them suffer the consequences of others, and passing on both the successes and failures in their own actions. Above all, they do their best to shape the choices and knowledge of their proteges so that they will be successful. Mentorship is a daily interaction and constant relationship that is fraught with successes and failures.
It’s a shame the military has not received similar treatment on mentorship as shows like this. I think it would give a much better window into what the military is, and isn’t, for society as a whole, as well as allow those serving to see how fluid and difficult leadership and mentorship truly is.
For what it’s worth, here are some aspects I think are ripe for portrayal on the small screen, and items that the military services and service members have yet to grapple with.
1. The effect of both “toxic” and phenomenal leaders on their subordinates .
Imagine a show that spent significant time on what types of leaders “mentors,” like former Brig. Gen. Jeffrey Sinclair, created in their wake. I’d posit his negative brand of mentorship and negative example as a role model would be a great foil for exploring the opposite, positive example, as well.
2. The difficulty in balancing time, work, family, and mentoring .
Like any relationship, mentoring takes significant time and energy and could be used to highlight the difficulties in work-life balance (and how mentorship falls right in between life and work).
3. The challenges in working up through an ossified bureaucracy.
No matter how influential and supportive a mentor may be, he or she cannot influence a system built on fairness over effectiveness. In-depth treatment of our personnel system and how mentors help proteges navigate them would be intriguing.
4. The personal reasons for continuing (or leaving) military service .
There are plenty of disheartening and vitriol-laden screeds on how the military services are “bleeding talent,” as well as numerous success stories of veterans who left the service and went on to serve their country in other ways. Treatment on the dynamics of such a decision would provide a phenomenal window into why people serve, how they transition when that service is complete, and where mentors fit into that process. How many mentors do you know that gave up their relationship with their proteges when they found out they were taking off the uniform (or, God-forbid, leaving a basic branch)?
There are dozens more dynamics that could be addressed in such a series. And while Hollywood would likely get a lot wrong in portraying our military, a true look at mentorship as a flawed and personal relationship with little effect on the bureaucracy is something that is way overdue.
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The United States will leave "a small peacekeeping group" of 200 American troops in Syria for a period of time after a U.S. pullout, the White House said on Thursday, as President Donald Trump pulled back from a complete withdrawal.
Trump claims border wall is under construction 'right now' using fence repair footage from 5 months ago
With a legal fight challenge mounting from state governments over the Trump administration's use of a national emergency to construct at the U.S.-Mexico border, the president has kicked his push for the barrier into high gear.
On Wednesday, President Trump tweeted a time-lapse video of wall construction in New Mexico; the next day, he proclaimed that "THE WALL IS UNDER CONSTRUCTION RIGHT NOW"
But there's a big problem: The footage, which was filmed more than five months ago on Sep. 18, 2018, isn't really new wall construction at all, and certainly not part of the ongoing construction of "the wall" that Trump has been haggling with Congress over.
Group of American vets detained in Haiti on weapons charges brought back to US, arrested upon landing
A group comprised of former U.S. military veterans and security contractors who were detained in Haiti on weapons charges has been brought back to the United States and arrested upon landing, The Miami-Herald reported.
The men — five Americans, two Serbs, and one Haitian — were stopped at a Port-au-Prince police checkpoint on Sunday while riding in two vehicles without license plates, according to police. When questioned, the heavily-armed men allegedly told police they were on a "government mission" before being taken into custody.
The Army allegedly missed this soldier's stomach cancer for 4 years. His widow wants someone to answer for it
The widow of a soldier whose stomach cancer was allegedly overlooked by Army doctors for four years is mounting a medical malpractice lawsuit against the military, but due to a decades-old legal rule known as the Feres Doctrine, her case will likely be dismissed before it ever goes to trial.
Hand grenades from the last major battle of the Revolutionary War have repeatedly scrambled bomb squads in Virginia's capital
In an uh-oh episode of historic proportions, hand grenades from the last major battle of the Revolutionary War recently and repeatedly scrambled bomb squads in Virginia's capital city.
Wait – they had hand grenades in the Revolutionary War? Indeed. Hollow iron balls, filled with black powder, outfitted with a fuse, then lit and thrown.
And more than two dozen have been sitting in cardboard boxes at the Department of Historic Resources, undetected for 30 years.