Blaming Islam For Paris Attacks Is Both Immoral and Bad Strategy

U.S. Army photo by Spc. Ben Hutto

On Nov. 13, three separate attacks in Paris shocked us. Without a doubt, the attacks in Paris were hideous. The perpetrators, planners, and supporters of these acts deserve nothing less than death. Following the attacks social media erupted with sympathy for the victims, but also vitriol and rage. Much outrage was, and continues, to be directed at the Islamic faith as a whole and specifically at the Syrian refugee population. These angry sentiments are counterproductive to an effective response. Anger is understandable, but not toward an entire religion or refugee population.

In any group there is a broad range of beliefs. Members of the Islamic faith are the same. It is a massive community with a wide spectrum of viewpoints. Some members of the Islamic faith are the enemies of the West, nothing less. Yet, others are not. Some of those could be enemies, but are not yet. Portions subscribe to versions of Islam that perpetuate and support terrorism, and other barbaric acts. There are some members of the Islamic faith who choose to be enemies of the West, while others are not; their choice of opposition is political. As politics shift, so do our future enemies and allies.

Reactions to the violence in Paris include wide-ranging calls for action. Some were responsible and prudent, like supporting France, military responses, and continued targeting of Islamic extremist groups. Yet, others were broadly hostile, describing the religion of Islam itself as the cause of violence. Many suggested that the attacks are a clear consequence of an “invasion of Syrian immigrants.” While authorities believe one terrorist posed as a refugee, five more were identified as French nationals. Still, anti-refugee hysteria continues to grow. In the United States, at least 27 state governors have declared they will refuse to accept Syrian refugees, a claim which is likely unenforceable.

Vitriol and demagoguery are useless expressions and run counter to good policy and strategy. I understand these reactions are seductive. From 2006 to 2008, I served as an infantry platoon leader in Baghdad with Alpha Company, 1-5 CAV. During the outbreak of sectarian violence, our sector of Baghdad became one of the few remaining Sunni strongholds in the capital. It was ugly and violent. Al Qaeda operated in our area and we endured significant casualties. Yet, on the May 19, 2007, everything changed. A deep buried improvised explosive device struck one of our patrols killing six soldiers and an interpreter. In the aftermath of this attack the local population braced for a harsh reaction. Instead the battalion leadership, then Lt. Col. Dale Kuehl, Maj. Chris Rogers, and Maj. Chip Daniels demonstrated incredible leadership, restraint, wisdom, and willpower.

A local leader contacted my command and offered to pursue al Qaeda. The command negotiated and reached an agreement that led to the establishment of a local security force and eventually the “Sons of Iraq” in Baghdad. Our battalion began executing “joint” patrols with members of the local security force by the end of May. Our operations were so effective that al Qaeda was forced to import fighters. By the end of July, they could no longer operate in our sector. From then, until we left in January 2008, our battalion was not the target of a single attack. Local businesses and schools reopened. Our sector had changed so drastically that I ate chicken in a crowd of Iraqis walking on a street that was too dangerous to drive a tank through several months before.

First, by refusing to respond rashly to al Qaeda’s provocations, my command team avoided making enemies of the locals. This decision created space for people who had tacitly allowed to group to operate, to become our allies. Our unit refused to adopt an “us vs. them” attitude toward the local Iraqi people. Again, this undercut the Islamic extremist propaganda. My battalion even held a joint memorial ceremony with the Iraqi public at the location where the May 19 IED attack took place, a symbolic gesture, but one that repudiated insurgent messaging efforts. Finally with assistance from the local security forces, we were able to focus our counterinsurgency efforts on the small minority of active insurgents. These efforts led to better intelligence, better operations, and elimination of the enemy’s ability to operate.

We should consider this example following the attacks in Paris. Those who choose to declare the religion of Islam and the Syrian refugees as enemies are wrong morally, but also strategically. First, proclaiming an entire group as the enemy casts too wide of net. It makes opponents of people who might have otherwise have been friends and allies. Second, it serves the purpose of violent Islamic groups like al Qaeda and the so-called Islamic State. These groups frame the relationship between the West and Islam as a battle for survival. Failing to distinguish between members of the Islamic faith and violent Islamic extremists validates this propaganda. An outpouring of anti-Islamic and anti-refugee sentiment is a gift for Islamic extremist recruitment. Third, too broadly classifying enemies creates difficulty in directing anti-terrorism efforts. When an entire group is designated suspect, counterterrorism operations risk being overwhelmed and thus overlooking credible threats; and while narrow counterterrorism efforts risk overlooking threats, their subsequent results tend to be more accurate. This allows of intelligent expansion of effort as targeting develops.

Terrorism is a global problem. In the 48 hours prior to the attack in Paris, there had been attacks in Kabul, Baghdad, and Beirut. As my friend and colleague Lemar Farhad expressed recently on Facebook: “The Paris attacks are not unbelievable, in fact [they are] very believable… the people of Iraq, Syria, and Afghanistan have experienced many days like this bloody Friday in Paris.”

This does not trivialize the events in France, but it demonstrates that the West has a common ally against Islamic extremists: Muslims. We must direct our attention toward those actually responsible for the attacks, extremists, and embrace the Islamic community and overcome the stigma surrounding it. Doing so helps us find allies and creative solutions to the complex problem of terrorism. When frenzied social media spews indirect anger at the Islamic community, it is helping Islamic extremism. Instead we should push back on those who claim we are in struggle with Islam itself. Finally, we should consider that the public’s voice informs the decisions of policymakers. Loud calls for indiscriminate action often become bad policy, which obscures and frustrates counterterrorism efforts. Instead we must encourage our leaders to embrace those who flee from oppression, because embracing the enemy of our enemy, those seeking freedom from tyranny and death, is both moral, and from a strategic viewpoint, pragmatic.

"It's kind of like the equivalent of dropping a soda can into canyon and putting on a blindfold and going and finding it, because you can't just look down and see it," diver Jeff Goodreau said of finding the wreck.

The USS Eagle 56 was only five miles off the coast of Maine when it exploded.

The World War I-era patrol boat split in half, then slipped beneath the surface of the North Atlantic. The Eagle 56 had been carrying a crew of 62. Rescuers pulled 13 survivors from the water that day. It was April 23, 1945, just two weeks before the surrender of Nazi Germany.

The U.S. Navy classified the disaster as an accident, attributing the sinking to a blast in the boiler room. In 2001, that ruling was changed to reflect the sinking as a deliberate act of war, perpetuated by German submarine U-853, a u-boat belonging to Nazi Germany's Kriegsmarine.

Still, despite the Navy's effort to clarify the circumstances surrounding the sinking, the Eagle 56 lingered as a mystery. The ship had sunk relatively close to shore, but efforts to locate the wreck were futile for decades. No one could find the Eagle 56, a small patrol ship that had come so close to making it back home.

Then, a group of friends and amateur divers decided to try to find the wreck in 2014. After years of fruitless dives and intensive research, New England-based Nomad Exploration Team successfully located the Eagle 56 in June 2018.

Business Insider spoke to two crew members — meat truck driver Jeff Goodreau and Massachusetts Department of Corrections officer Donald Ferrara — about their discovery.

Read More Show Less
(CIA photo)

Before the 5th Special Forces Group's Operational Detachment Alpha 595, before 160th Special Operations Aviation Regiment's MH-47E Chinooks, and before the Air Force combat controllers, there were a handful of CIA officers and a buttload of cash.

Read More Show Less

The last time the world saw Marine veteran Austin Tice, he had been taken prisoner by armed men. It was unclear whether his captors were jihadists or allies of Syrian dictator Bashar al Assad who were disguised as Islamic radicals.

Blindfolded and nearly out of breath, Tice spoke in Arabic before breaking into English:"Oh Jesus. Oh Jesus."

That was from a video posted on YouTube on Sept. 26, 2012, several weeks after Tice went missing near Damascus, Syria, while working as a freelance journalist for McClatchy and the Washington Post.

Now that Tice has been held in captivity for more than seven years, reporters who have regular access to President Donald Trump need to start asking him how he is going to bring Tice home.

Read More Show Less

"Shoots like a carbine, holsters like a pistol." That's the pitch behind the new Flux Defense system designed to transform the Army's brand new sidearm into a personal defense weapon.

Read More Show Less

Sometimes a joke just doesn't work.

For example, the Defense Visual Information Distribution Service tweeted and subsequently deleted a Gilbert Gottfried-esque misfire about the "Storm Area 51" movement.

On Friday DVIDSHUB tweeted a picture of a B-2 bomber on the flight line with a formation of airmen in front of it along with the caption: "The last thing #Millenials will see if they attempt the #area51raid today."

Read More Show Less