To Cut Taxpayer Costs, Commissaries Have To Close, New Report Says

news
Joint Base Myer-Henderson Hall PAO photo by Nell King

Editor’s Note: This article by Amy Bushatz originally appeared on Military.com, the premier source of information for the military and veteran community.


Shutting down all U.S. military commissaries is the only way for the system to operate without any cost to taxpayers, according to a new Defense Department report — a move officials say they don't want to do.

"We have concluded that budget neutrality could not be reached through store closures unless the commissary system is shut down completely," states the report on cost savings at the Defense Commissary Agency.

The study was ordered by Congress last year and released this week.

"The Department determined that such changes would undermine the commissary benefit and reduce exchange system patronage, significantly diminishing resale benefits to service members, retirees, their families and the military services," Peter Levin, acting undersecretary of defense for defense personnel and readiness, wrote in a letter to lawmakers submitted with the report.

"As a result, the Department has rejected these alternatives," he wrote.

What the agency and the exchanges can do without impacting the military's Morale, Welfare and Recreation funds or customer service is reduce their reliance on federal funding by about $2 billion over five years, or about $300 million per year starting in 2019, the report states.

The could happen by raising the prices on some products while working with manufacturers to the lower the price of others — programs that are already in the works. But savings through those measures falls $1.5 billion short of the desired cut in 2019 alone, the report notes, and requires Congress to make permanent the price changes previously allowed as a test measure.

Lawmakers have sought for several years to eliminate the commissary system's reliance on $1.4 billion in annual funding from Congress.

Because goods at the commissary are currently, by law, sold at cost plus a 5% surcharge, there is no sales revenue in the system to cover operation costs. Income from the surcharge covers the cost of buildings and infrastructure maintenance, while the annual government funding pays for other overhead including employee salaries and the cost of shipping food and goods worldwide.

Lawmakers have proposed a variety of cost-slashing plans including eliminating the taxpayer subsidy, raising prices at commissaries to cover operation costs, combining the commissary and exchange systems, and privatizing commissaries through contracts with civilian grocers.

Of those options, the only semi-viable solution could be privatization, but research and past attempts — such as a 1983 pilot at Yuma Proving Ground, Arizona — showed that even that could fail and comes with a variety of major pitfalls, the report states.

"The conclusion generally reached by the past debates and studies was that privatization … was not an effective method of reducing the Department's budget for several reasons," it states. "Nonetheless, the debate continues."

For the new study, officials reached out to officials at 10 private companies to look at how privatization could work today. Of those, three agreed to a discussion through a set of standardized questions. Each company suggested a different form of privatization, officials wrote, including only privatizing stores near their existing locations and leasing the commissaries on bases.

As a result of their research, officials are conducting further outreach to the grocery industry through a request for information that could help further hash-out a privatization path, officials wrote in the report. That request closes July 15.

The article originally appeared on Military.com.

More from Military.com:

Construction crews staged material needed for the Santa Teresa Border Wall Replacement project near the Santa Teresa Port of Entry. (U.S. Customs and Border Patrol/Mani Albrecht)

With a legal fight challenge mounting from state governments over the Trump administration's use of a national emergency to construct at the U.S.-Mexico border, the president has kicked his push for the barrier into high gear.

On Wednesday, President Trump tweeted a time-lapse video of wall construction in New Mexico; the next day, he proclaimed that "THE WALL IS UNDER CONSTRUCTION RIGHT NOW"

But there's a big problem: The footage, which was filmed more than five months ago on Sep. 18, 2018, isn't really new wall construction at all, and certainly not part of the ongoing construction of "the wall" that Trump has been haggling with Congress over.

Read More Show Less
(From left to right) Chris Osman, Chris McKinley, Kent Kroeker, and Talon Burton

A group comprised of former U.S. military veterans and security contractors who were detained in Haiti on weapons charges has been brought back to the United States and arrested upon landing, The Miami-Herald reported.

The men — five Americans, two Serbs, and one Haitian — were stopped at a Port-au-Prince police checkpoint on Sunday while riding in two vehicles without license plates, according to police. When questioned, the heavily-armed men allegedly told police they were on a "government mission" before being taken into custody.

Read More Show Less
Army Sgt. Jeremy Seals died on Oct. 31, 2018, following a protracted battle with stomach cancer. His widow, Cheryl Seals is mounting a lawsuit alleging that military care providers missed her husband's cancer. Task & Purpose photo illustration by Aaron Provost

The widow of a soldier whose stomach cancer was allegedly overlooked by Army doctors for four years is mounting a medical malpractice lawsuit against the military, but due to a decades-old legal rule known as the Feres Doctrine, her case will likely be dismissed before it ever goes to trial.

Read More Show Less
The first grenade core was accidentally discovered on Nov. 28, 2018, by Virginia Department of Historic Resources staff examining relics recovered from the Betsy, a British ship scuttled during the last major battle of the Revolutionary War. The grenade's iron jacket had dissolved, but its core of black powder remained potent. Within a month or so, more than two dozen were found. (Virginia Department of Historic Resources via The Virginian-Pilot)

In an uh-oh episode of historic proportions, hand grenades from the last major battle of the Revolutionary War recently and repeatedly scrambled bomb squads in Virginia's capital city.

Wait – they had hand grenades in the Revolutionary War? Indeed. Hollow iron balls, filled with black powder, outfitted with a fuse, then lit and thrown.

And more than two dozen have been sitting in cardboard boxes at the Department of Historic Resources, undetected for 30 years.

Read More Show Less

A Coast Guard lieutenant arrested this week planned to "murder innocent civilians on a scale rarely seen in this country," according to a court filing requesting he be detained until his trial.

Read More Show Less