DEBATE THIS: Which Video Game Better Represents Military Life: Battlefield 4 Or Mass Effect?

Debates

THE FACTS: Battlefield and Mass Effect have become two of the biggest game franchises of the past decade from publisher EA Games. Developed by Swedish games studio Digital Illusions CE, the Battlefield series began in 2002 with Battlefield 1942, a groundbreaking, multiplayer first-person-shooter that featured 64-player combat on the famous battlefields of World War II. The hallmark of all Battlefield games is the large-scale combined arms experience, with armor, aircraft, and naval vessels supporting infantry in huge online maps. Legendary role-playing-game developer Bioware created a whole new universe with the release of Mass Effect in 2007. The trilogy of Mass Effect games chronicles Commander Shepard's struggle against galaxy-ending threats and the difficult choices he must make along the way. In addition to the sci-fi action, the narrative is driven by Commander Shepard's relationships with the trilogy's many characters and the difficult moral decisions they face. While both games are extremely popular among service members and veterans alike, which one reflects a more realistic military experience?

Bryan Parent Veteran Team Co-Lead, Operation Supply Drop Los AngelesU.S. Army, 2005-2011@OSD_LosAngeles

Battlefield 4 brings a lot of things to the table that remind me of my ACH-wearing days. Of my biggest pet peeves from old "combat simulators" was when I unloaded a dozen rounds from an assault rifle into a flimsy wall the bad guy was behind, never making a dent. So while I could sit behind a couch in Mass Effect for days when engaging a Collector, in Battlefield 4, you quickly learn the difference between cover and concealment.

Also, in Battlefield 4, you better take into account the fact that the guy is 300 yards down the end of your barrel when you pull the trigger. Adjust for the drop in your round, and you can take care of your target quickly. Don't, and you've just given away your team's position. Even the fanciest rifle should still abide by the laws of physics, but I never had to account for gravity in Mass Effect 1, 2, or 3.
This doesn't even account for the other aspects of the game play that remind me of my days in uniform. The ego-pissing contests between characters, the banter going up and down the chain of command, the guy with more patches and "flair" on his kit than Brian from Office Space — these are all very real element of military life that other games neglect.
So if you're looking for a dose of real life, don't look up to space, just keep your eyes on target at Battlefield 4.

Don Gomez U.S. Army, 2001-Present@dongomezjr

I've never been a big fan of Ghost Recon, Call of Duty, Battlefield, or any of the other "realistic" first-person shooters. They are flashy, visually stunning, and sometimes fun, but simple in their execution. For the most part, you navigate your avatar across a generally linear course, destroying everything in your path. Those games reflect the exciting, but proportionally minute experiences of wartime service. Even out on the tip of the spear, firefights full of explosions and sprinting around the battlefield happen infrequently.

While "realistic" first-person shooters might capture what military gear looks like and the sights and sounds of combat, Mass Effect does a better job at capturing the feel of military life.
The key events driving the plot are the decisions made in non-combat situations, interactions between leaders, subordinates, and outsiders, and the development of relationships over time. Mass Effect has its share of combat, but combat happens less frequently and chaotically, and usually between long periods of "inactivity" filled by user-driven dialogue, planning, and preparation.
The protagonist's choices across the series have real consequences for the player and the universe he or she inhabits. The dialogue choices made when speaking with teammates can either build or erode the trust and cohesion of the fighting force. The application of force is weighed against sympathy and aid in key decisions, when the right answer is not always apparent. Act too harshly and you risk alienating potential allies. Too soft and you open yourself to exploitation.
These nuances seem much more familiar to my military experience than anything I've seen in any "realistic" combat games.

(The News & Observer courtesy photo / Richard Stradling)

Seventy-five years ago Wednesday, Fred Reidenbach was aboard a Navy patrol craft loaded with radio gear, helping to coordinate the landing at Iwo Jima, a volcanic island the U.S. military hoped to use as a staging area for the eventual invasion of Japan.

Reidenbach was a 22-year-old sergeant with the 4th Marine Division from Rochester, New York, and recalls that it was cold that day. The Marines were issued sweaters, heavy socks and 2.5 ounces of brandy to steel them for the task ahead: dislodging 21,000 Japanese soldiers from heavily fortified bunkers and tunnels. Reidenbach wasn't a drinker but didn't have trouble finding someone to take his brandy.

"I passed it on to somebody who liked it better than me," he said.

Read More
Army recruiters hold a swearing-in ceremony for over 40 of Arkansas' Future Soldiers at the Arkansas State Capital Building. (U.S. Army/Amber Osei)

Though the Army has yet to actually set an official recruiting goal for this year, leaders are confident they're going to bring in more soldiers than last year.

Maj. Gen. Frank Muth, head of Army Recruiting Command, told reporters on Wednesday that the Army was currently 2,226 contracts ahead of where it was in 2019.

"I will just tell you that this time last year we were in the red, and now we're in the green which is — the momentum's there and we see it continuing throughout the end of the year," Muth said, adding that the service hit recruiting numbers in February that haven't been hit during that month since 2014.

Read More
In this June 16, 2018 photo, Taliban fighters greet residents in the Surkhroad district of Nangarhar province, east of Kabul, Afghanistan, (AP Photo/Rahmat Gul)

KABUL/WASHINGTON/PESHAWAR, Pakistan (Reuters) - The United States and the Taliban will sign an agreement on Feb. 29 at the end of a week long period of violence reduction in Afghanistan, U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo and the Taliban said on Friday.

Read More
A U.S. Army UH-60L Black Hawk crew chief with the New Jersey National Guard's 1-171st General Support Aviation Battalion stands for a portrait at the Army Aviation Support Facility on Joint Base McGuire-Dix-Lakehurst, N.J., Feb. 3, 2020 (Air National Guard photo / Master Sgt. Matt Hecht)

Active-duty service members, Reservists and National Guard members often serve side-by-side performing highly skilled and dangerous jobs, such as parachuting, explosives demolition and flight deck operations.

Reservists and Guard members are required to undergo the same training as specialized active-duty troops, and they face the same risks. Yet the extra incentive pay they receive for their work — called hazardous duty incentive pay — is merely a fraction of what their active-duty counterparts receive for performing the same job.

A bipartisan group of lawmakers, led by U.S. Rep. Andy Kim, D-3 of Moorestown, are partnering on legislation to correct the inequity. Known as the Guard and Reserve Hazard Duty Pay Equity Act, the bill seeks to standardize payment of hazardous duty incentive pay for all members of the armed services, including Reserve and National Guard components.

Read More
A screen grab from a YouTube video shows Marines being arrested during formation at Camp Pendleton in July, 2019. (Screen capture)

Editor's Note: This article by Gina Harkins originally appeared on Military.com, a leading source of news for the military and veteran community.

Another Marine was hit with jail time and a bad-conduct discharge in connection with a slew of arrests made last summer over suspicions that members of a California-based infantry battalion were transporting people who'd crossed into the U.S. illegally.

Read More