Do we really need a remake of 'The Dirty Dozen?'


What Lee Marvin's exact expression would be if he heard this news.


Editor's Note: This article by James Barber originally appeared on, a leading source of news for the military and veteran community.

The Dirty Dozen might just be the perfect World War II movie. That doesn't mean it has anything to do with the reality of the war or the military justice system, but it's a war movie that does seem to get better every single time you see it.

Lee Marvin is an officer assigned to cobble together a unit that will kill Nazi officers before the D-Day invasion and must draw from a pool of military convicts facing life sentences or the death penalty. If the guys sign up for the suicide mission, they'll have their slate wiped clean if they succeed and return alive.

If you've never seen the movie (or if you just haven't watched it in the last week), it's streaming now on Netflix. Shut off the phones and the internet and enjoy the next 2.5 hours.

The Dirty Dozen - Trailer

The all-star cast features Ernest Borgnine, Charles Bronson, NFL great Jim Brown, John Cassavetes, Robert Ryan, Donald Sutherland, George Kennedy, Telly Savalas, Robert Webber, Clint Walker, Richard Jaeckl, Robert Webber, Ralph Meeker and pop singer Trini Lopez. That's a murderer's row of film noir and action movie stars and character actors all in the same picture. It's pretty much perfect from start to finish.

OK, so here's the thing: Warner Bros. has decided to enlist director David Ayer for a "contemporized remake." What does that even mean? Will it be a Tarantino-style insertion of modern sensibilities into a WWII movie, along the lines of "Inglourious Basterds" or "The 14 Fists of McCluskey"?

Or will it be a truly contemporary tale? Does the modern military have a pool of death penalty prisoners to blackmail into a suicide mission? Who would be the enemy target? Can it even be a war movie if it's set in the present day?

The main reason for hope here is David Ayer, a writer and director who's shown a particular talent for writing about cops and the military. He directed Denzel Washington in "Training Day" and won him an Oscar (and also got Ethan Hawke a Best Supporting Actor nomination).

He wrote a pair of bent-cop classics in "Dark Blue" and "Street Kings" (and directed the latter). He made up for those by writing and directing "End of Watch," one of the greatest good cop movies ever.

Ayer also wrote and directed the underrated WWII tank movie "Fury" and the perhaps-only-loved-by-me-but-really-loved-by-me bent DEA agent thriller "Sabotage."

Things went off the rails a bit with "Suicide Squad," which is pretty much a rip-off of The Dirty Dozen anyway. He recovered with the Netflix mutant cop thriller "Bright," a great modern action picture.

So, if anyone just has to take another shot at a Dirty Dozen movie, Ayer would be the #1 guy on my list to try. No matter what, the movie he makes is guaranteed to be better than any of the three sequels to The Dirty Dozen made in the late '80s. If you've never seen them, please make sure you don't.

This article originally appeared on

More articles from

Roughly a dozen U.S. troops showing concussion-related symptoms are being medically evacuated from Al-Asad Air Base in Iraq to Landstuhl Regional Medical Center in Germany, a defense official told Task & Purpose on Tuesday.

Read More

In a Galaxy — err, I mean, on a military base far, far away, soldiers are standing in solidarity with galactic freedom fighters.

Sitting at the top of an Army press release from March 2019, regarding the East Africa Response Force's deployment to Gabon, the photo seems, at first glance, just like any other: Soldiers on the move.

But if you look closer at the top right, you'll find something spectacular: A Rebel Alliance flag.

Read More
The maiden flight of the first CMV-22B Osprey took place in Amarillo, Texas (Courtesy photo)

The first of the CMV-22B Osprey tiltrotor aircraft the Navy plans on adopting as its carrier onboard delivery (COD) aircraft of choice has successfully completed its first flight operations, manufacturer Boeing announced on Tuesday.

Read More
A soldier plugs his ears during a live fire mission at Yakima Training Center. Photo: Capt. Leslie Reed/U.S. Army

Another 300 lawsuits against 3M flooded federal courts this month as more military veterans accuse the behemoth manufacturer of knowingly making defective earplugs that caused vets to lose hearing during combat in Iraq or Afghanistan or while training on U.S. military bases.

On another front, 3M also is fighting lawsuits related to a class of chemicals known as PFAS, with the state of Michigan filing a lawsuit last week against the Maplewood-based company.

To date, nearly 2,000 U.S. veterans from Minnesota to California and Texas have filed more than 1,000 lawsuits.

Read More

GENEVA (Reuters) - North Korea said on Tuesday it was no longer bound by commitments to halt nuclear and missile testing, blaming the United States' failure to meet a year-end deadline for nuclear talks and "brutal and inhumane" U.S. sanctions.

North Korean leader Kim Jong Un set an end-December deadline for denuclearization talks with the United States and White House national security adviser Robert O'Brien said at the time the United States had opened channels of communication.

O'Brien said then he hoped Kim would follow through on denuclearization commitments he made at summits with U.S. President Donald Trump.

Read More