Health Care ‘Choice’ For Veterans Could Leave Many Without Options

Opinion
Fairchild Air Force Base active and Guard leadership tour the Spokane Veterans Affairs Medical Center while talking to staff and veterans in Spokane, Wash., Feb. 14, 2014.
Photo by SSgt Alex Montes

After three years of crisis and controversy, the Department of Veterans Affairs has reached a watershed moment, and decisions about how to strengthen and reform its health care system must be made this year. The central element of this debate lies in the design — how can we create new care options for veterans outside the VA without inhibiting access or reducing quality for those who choose and rely on the VA system?


Since the waiting list scandal at Phoenix VA exploded in the spring of 2014, the idea of providing veterans with more choices has been a key part of discussions over how to improve veterans’ health care. However, some politicians and political organizations have promoted solutions that focus more on providing veterans with “choice” than with the best possible health care outcomes.

Unfortunately, the frequent use of the term choice — without any clear definition or specifics – has only added to the complexity and confusion of this debate. To help clarify matters, DAV recently launched a new video, “Putting Choice in Context,” along with accompanying social media and grassroots efforts, to educate veterans and policymakers about what choice could really mean.

For example, some people have said that choice would allow veterans the ability to pick their own doctors. But since many doctors don’t accept choice payment rates, relying on choice could leave veterans without the ability to find a qualified physician. Some have claimed that providing all veterans with choice would lead to better quality health care; however, independent studies by Rand Corp. and others have consistently shown that VA already provides equal or better care than the private sector and that choice will lead to more fragmented care, which correlates with worse health outcomes. Finally, some say that choice will increase access, but this isn’t true for millions of veterans. If choice expands and moves more veterans to the private sector, VA would be forced to close some hospitals and clinics and reduce medical services in others, disrupting service for millions of veterans who rely on VA and limiting their options for care.     

After 18 months of debate, the congressionally mandated Commission on Care reached the same conclusion as DAV, other veterans groups, the VA and many members of Congress — the best way to improve veterans’ health care is to create an integrated network combining the strength of the VA system with the best of private care. With a new president, VA secretary, and Congress in place, it’s critical that any debate over choice consider the cost, impact on VA, and the resulting consequences for veterans, particularly disabled veterans. As the new administration and Congress begin to debate VA health care reform this year, choice must be considered in the context of the overall VA health care system.

Ed Mahoney/Kickstarter

In June 2011 Iraq's defense minister announced that U.S. troops who had deployed to the country would receive the Iraq Commitment Medal in recognition of their service. Eight years later, millions of qualified veterans have yet to receive it.

The reason: The Iraqi government has so far failed to provide the medals to the Department of Defense for approval and distribution.

A small group of veterans hopes to change that.

Read More Show Less
F-16 Fighting Falcon (Photo: US Air Force)

For a cool $8.5 million, you could be the proud owner of a "fully functioning" F-16 A/B Fighting Falcon fighter jet that a South Florida company acquired from Jordan.

The combat aircraft, which can hit a top speed of 1,357 mph at 40,000 feet, isn't showroom new — it was built in 1980. But it still has a max range of 2,400 miles and an initial climb rate of 62,000 feet per minute and remains militarized, according to The Drive, an automotive website that also covers defense topics, WBDO News 96.5 reported Wednesday.

Read More Show Less
FILE PHOTO: Russian President Vladimir Putin meets with FIFA President Gianni Infantino at the Kremlin in Moscow, Russia February 20, 2019. Yuri Kadobnov/Pool via REUTERS

MOSCOW (Reuters) - Russian authorities said on Friday that a doctor who treated those injured in a mysterious accident this month had the radioactive isotope Caesium-137 in his body, but said it was probably put there by his diet.

The deadly accident at a military site in northern Russia took place on Aug. 8 and caused a brief spurt of radiation. Russian President Vladimir Putin later said it occurred during testing of what he called promising new weapons systems.

Read More Show Less
The U.S. Air Force Thunderbirds perform a fly-over as newly graduated cadets from the U. S. Air Force Academy toss their hats at the conclusion of their commencement ceremony in Colorado Springs, Colorado, May 23, 2018. Shortly after the event ceremony's commencement, the Thunderbirds put on an aerial demonstration show. (U.S. Air Force photo by Senior Airman Dennis Hoffman)

Groundwater at the Air Force Academy is contaminated with the same toxic chemicals polluting a southern El Paso County aquifer, expanding a problem that has cost tens of millions of dollars to address in the Pikes Peak region.

Plans are underway to begin testing drinking water wells south of the academy in the Woodmen Valley area after unsafe levels of the chemicals were found at four locations on base, the academy said Thursday.

Read More Show Less