Lawmaker's Plan To Institute Military Oath Against Suicide Could Backfire, Experts Say

Veterans Benefits

A congressman who served in Afghanistan is championing an idea to request departing servicemembers sign an oath not to harm themselves, as a method to deter veteran suicides.

But some suicide prevention experts contend the plan is likely to do the opposite.

Rep. Brian Mast, R-Fla., who took office this January, is an Army veteran who lost both of his legs in 2010 from a roadside bomb explosion in Kandahar. When promoting the “Oath of Exit” on the House floor last month, Mast said servicemembers are known for honoring their commitments – and if they commit to contacting fellow veterans before harming themselves, they’d do it.

Though it’s well-intentioned, the oath – essentially a no-suicide contract – is an outdated notion proven not to work, and it could even backfire, some experts said.

“It won’t work, to put it bluntly,” said Craig Bryan, a psychologist and executive director of the National Center for Veterans Studies at the University of Utah. “At best, it would be a neutral effect, but it could make things worse.”

When struggling with suicidal thoughts, veterans who sign the commitment could feel an increased sense of shame and guilt, Bryan explained.

U.S. House Representative Brian Mast of Florida meets with members of Marine Rotational Force Europe 17.1 (MRF-E) at Vaernes Garrison, Norway, April 18, 2017.U.S. Marine Corps photo

Caitlin Thompson, the former director of suicide prevention programs at the Department of Veterans Affairs, agreed. Experts in suicide prevention have been discouraging these types of contracts for the past 10 years, she said.

“It isn’t just that it didn’t work. It actually had the opposite effect,” said Thompson, who is now a vice president of Cohen Veterans Network. “It made it so that the person who signed it wouldn’t talk with their provider about feeling suicidal because of this fear of, ‘I signed this promise’.”

The oath was included in the 2018 National Defense Authorization Act that passed the House on July 14. Senators are on recess for the next few weeks but are expected to take up work on the NDAA after they return Sept. 5.

Mast said he created the bill with the goal of reducing veteran suicides.

The oath would be voluntary.

The VA analyzed millions of veterans’ records and reported last year that an average of 20 veterans died from suicide each day in 2014. While veterans made up only about 8.5 percent of the U.S. population in 2014, they accounted for 18 percent of suicides.

“Nearly every week I hear from a veteran who is thinking about taking their own life; maybe walking into their garage, turning on their car and never coming out,” Mast said on the House floor. “The idea for this came from friends of mine who had struggled with suicidal thoughts leaving the military. People who have actually been there on the edge.”

The American Psychological Association is asking senators to keep the oath out of the NDAA.

“The ‘Oath of Exit’ language… could backfire in lethal ways, by discouraging help-seeking among veterans in crisis and engendering a false sense of security among those to whom the oath is given,” Heather O’Beirne Kelly, director of military and veterans health policy for APA, wrote in an email.

Kelly said the APA wants the Defense Department and VA to use evidence-based suicide prevention practices.

Bryan, an Iraq war veteran, led a study comparing the effectiveness of no-suicide contracts with an alternative approach -- to create a crisis-response plan people can use when struggling with suicidal thoughts. The study was published in January in the Journal of Affective Disorders.

Researchers studied active-duty soldiers at Fort Carson, Colo., who had gone to a health care provider for a mental health crisis.

During a six-month period, more soldiers who signed a no-suicide contract attempted suicide than did soldiers who received a crisis-response plan. Crisis response planning was also found to result in a faster decline in suicidal thoughts and fewer inpatient hospitalizations, according to the study.

Cpl. Leonard Trevor participates in a scenario during Apply Suicide Intervention Skills Training, Sept. 16, 2016, at Camp Foster, Okinawa, Japan.U.S. Marine Corps photo

Bryan compared his crisis-response plan to CPR – anyone can do it if they’re trained, and it could help save someone’s life before they can get to a hospital or clinic, he said. It involves talking with someone about how they got to that point, warning signs and strategies to manage stress, and identifying people who could be supportive and reasons they have for living. They combine those things with a list of resources, such as health care providers and the number of a suicide hotline, onto an index card.

Thompson described a similar approach to Bryan’s crisis-response plan that’s implemented at the VA and clinics in the Cohen Veterans Network.

“Veterans can keep it in their wallets, or there’s an iPhone app you can put this all in,” Thompson said. “If you start feeling that way, you can immediately jump to your safety plan.”

The Defense Department funded Bryan’s research that pit the crisis-response plan against no-suicide contracts, as well as an earlier study he conducted into military and veteran suicide prevention. He said it is frustrating to think the Oath of Exit could become practice in the military while the crisis-response plan goes unimplemented.

“We are at a critical juncture, whether we’re going to put these solutions into practice or not, and that’s a question I think we have to answer as a society, and policymakers have to answer as well,” Bryan said.

No-suicide or no-harm contracts used to be common. Though other health care providers may still use them, Thompson said it stopped being standard practice about 10 years ago, when studies began getting published that showed they had no, or negative, effect.

She penned a post on the Cohen Veterans Network website last week after hearing about the Oath of Exit provision, discouraging it.

“When you hear about something that might be going against what actually works, it really is of grave concern,” Thompson said. “Nowhere in the VA or other spaces where suicide prevention is taken seriously does that exist. A community of clinicians and researchers have continued to try to get the word out that this doesn’t work.”


©2017 the Stars and Stripes. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

Photo by Sgt. Justin A. Moeller
(U.S. Air Force)

Two airmen were administratively punished for drinking at the missile launch control center for 150 nuclear LGM-30G Minuteman III intercontinental ballistic missiles at F.E. Warren Air Force Base in Wyoming, the Air Force confirmed to Task & Purpose on Friday.

Read More Show Less

Two F-35A Lightning II Joint Strike Fighters recently flew a mission in the Middle East in "beast mode," meaning they were loaded up with as much firepower as they could carry.

The F-35s with the 4th Expeditionary Fighter Squadron took off from Al Dhafra Air Base, United Arab Emirates to execute a mission in support of U.S. forces in Afghanistan, Air Forces Central Command revealed. The fifth-generation fighters sacrificed their high-end stealth to fly with a full loadout of weaponry on their wings.

Read More Show Less
(DoD photos)

The U.S. Senate closed out the week before Memorial Day by confirming Gen. James McConville as the Army's new chief of staff and Adm. Bill Moran as the Navy's new chief of naval operations.

McConville, previously vice chief of staff of the Army, was confirmed on Thursday along with his successor, Lt Gen. Joseph Marin. Moran, currently vice chief of naval operations, was confirmed Friday along with his successor, Vice Adm. Robert Burke.

Read More Show Less

Wright-Patterson Air Force Base is prohibiting service members who work there from being in the area of a Ku Klux Klan rally scheduled for Saturday in downtown Dayton, Ohio.

Read More Show Less
(Associated Press/Elise Amendola)

The Pentagon is producing precisely diddly-squat in terms of proof that Iran is behind recent attacks in the Middle East, requiring more U.S. troops be sent to the region.

Adm. Michael Gilday, director of the Joint Staff, said on Friday that the U.S. military is extending the deployment of about 600 troops with four Patriot missile batteries already in the region and sending close to 1,000 other service members to the Middle East in response to an Iranian "campaign" against U.S. forces.

Read More Show Less