No, hazing doesn't teach discipline. It actually does the opposite

Vultures' Row
Recruit Training Fourth Phase

Editor's Note: The following is an op-ed. The opinions expressed are those of the author, and do not necessarily reflect the views of Task & Purpose.

Marine Corps boot camp is renowned for turning young men and women from civilians into Marines. It is rightfully known as the most rigorous recruit training in the US military, but for some drill instructors, it just wasn't tough enough.

The Washington Post recently obtained documents detailing incidents wherein over 20 Marines have been disciplined for misconduct just at MCRD San Diego, one of two recruit depots, since 2017. That year is relevant, because Marine recruit training was supposed to be reset after the 2016 suicide death of Pvt. Raheel Siddiqui, who killed himself after being viciously hazed, which included racial and ethnic slurs and being put in an industrial clothes dryer.


The newly uncovered incidents include drill instructors assaulting recruits, as well as more inventive measures, such as using a staple gun on a recruit or being ordered to eat a pine cone. A quick look at the comment section on the Post as well as on other sites covering the controversy shows that plenty of vets think this sort of thing is okay, maybe even a good thing. Whether online or in person, such statements are often accompanied by apocryphal stories about some horrible event that happened during that person's boot camp experience.

Maybe the stories are true. Maybe they aren't. If they are, it illustrates a couple of things. First, just like abused children, those abused in the military are more likely to abuse others themselves when they get the chance. Second, everyone thinks that the generation after theirs is somehow lesser than their own, no matter the evidence to the contrary. Because of this, they need to be whipped into shape just as, or more so, than earlier generations.

Maybe it's worth breaking down what the goals of military training are in general, and recruit training in particular. The services have varying degrees of flowery language for their recruit training mission statements. The Navy's is very concrete, with a concise description of training goals: "...transform civilians into smartly disciplined, physically fit, basically trained Sailors…"

"Basically trained," teaching a particular set of knowledge to recruits. That's done in classrooms and by practice. "Physically fit," or being able to run, march, lift things, etc. That's done by conditioning programs. Neither of those objectives are helped by physical abuse. Never once in the history of instruction has getting hit helped anyone learn faster.

"But it will give them a good incentive to learn!" Which brings us to discipline, the practice of self-control and obedience to orders. Hazing represents the opposite. A significant percentage of the time it is the product of a lack of self-control and laziness. The hazer's temper or underlying cruelty gets the better of him and he takes that loss of self-control out on someone under his authority. Or the hazer knows there are any number of sanctioned methods to issue corrections, from extra military instruction to formal disciplinary action, but such things actually take time and effort.

The other part of discipline is obedience to orders. Considering that every service has myriad orders and regulations prohibiting hazing it's pretty odd to break orders to try to teach a subordinate how to follow orders, isn't it? Are you saying, for example, that you know more about training Marines than the Commandant or Sergeant Major of the Marine Corps? Are you contending that when the Commandant issued all those orders, he was winking at the time and didn't really mean it?

The services give their leaders from recruit training on up countless tools to improve performance and correct mistakes and misconduct. If you don't have the time or resources to properly use them, then that's something you need to take up your chain of command, not out on subordinates.

Could there be more tools in leaders' toolboxes? Probably. The Marine Corps has experimented with bringing back the Correctional Custody Unit, wherein low-grade offenders spend thirty days in an environment of hard labor and rigorous training, but that is tightly controlled and regulated.

Could training be more demanding? Of course. Get that syllabus or training and readiness manual revised to add more and tougher training, then. You don't get to give subordinates beatdowns on humiliate them just because higher hasn't allowed enough time to PT them.

But if your method of enforcing discipline is itself a breakdown of discipline, it's you that has the issue, not your subordinate.

Carl Forsling is a senior columnist for Task & Purpose. He is a Marine MV-22B pilot and former CH-46E pilot who retired from the military after 20 years of service. He is the father of two children and a graduate of Boston University and The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania. Follow him on Twitter @CarlForsling


In this March 12, 2016, file photo, Marines of the U.S., left, and South Korea, wearing blue headbands on their helmets, take positions after landing on a beach during the joint military combined amphibious exercise, called Ssangyong, part of the Key Resolve and Foal Eagle military exercises, in Pohang, South Korea. (Associated Press/Yonhap/Kim Jun-bum)

BANGKOK (Reuters) - The United States and South Korea said on Sunday they will postpone upcoming military drills in an effort to bolster a stalled peace push with North Korea, even as Washington denied the move amounted to another concession to Pyongyang.

The drills, known as the Combined Flying Training Event, would have simulated air combat scenarios and involved an undisclosed number of warplanes from both the United States and South Korea.

Read More Show Less

An opening ceremony will be held Monday on Hawaii island for a military exercise with China that will involve about 100 People's Liberation Army soldiers training alongside U.S. Army counterparts.

This comes after Adm. Phil Davidson, head of U.S. Indo-Pacific Command, spoke on Veterans Day at Punchbowl cemetery about the "rules-based international order" that followed U.S. victory in the Pacific in World War II, and China's attempts to usurp it.

Those American standards "are even more important today," Davidson said, "as malicious actors like the Communist Party of China seek to redefine the international order through corruption, malign cyber activities, intellectual property theft, restriction of individual liberties, military coercion and the direct attempts to override other nations' sovereignty."

Read More Show Less

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. President Donald Trump on Sunday told North Korean leader Kim Jong Un to "act quickly" to reach a deal with the United States, in a tweet weighing in on North Korea's criticism of his political rival former Vice President Joe Biden.

Trump, who has met Kim three times since 2018 over ending the North's missile and nuclear programs, addressed Kim directly, referring to the one-party state's ruler as "Mr. Chairman".

In his tweet, Trump told Kim, "You should act quickly, get the deal done," and hinted at a further meeting, signing off "See you soon!"

Read More Show Less

It is impossible to tune out news about the impeachment inquiry into President Donald Trump now that the hearings have become public. And this means that cable news networks and Congress are happier than pigs in manure: this story will dominate the news for the foreseeable future unless Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt get back together.

But the wall-to-wall coverage of impeachment mania has also created a news desert. To those of you who would rather emigrate to North Korea than watch one more lawmaker grandstand for the cameras, I humbly offer you an oasis of news that has absolutely nothing to do with Washington intrigue.

Read More Show Less

MOSCOW (Reuters) - Russia will return three captured naval ships to Ukraine on Monday and is moving them to a handover location agreed with Kiev, Crimea's border guard service was cited as saying by Russian news agencies on Sunday.

A Reuters reporter in Crimea, which Russian annexed from Ukraine in 2014, earlier on Sunday saw coastguard boats pulling the three vessels through the Kerch Strait toward the Black Sea where they could potentially be handed over to Ukraine.

Read More Show Less