Marine Corps Blames Human Error For Helicopter Window That Fell Near Crowded Elementary School

A CH-53E Super Stallion assigned to Marine Heavy Helicopter Squadron 462 hovers above a landing support specialist Marine waiting to hook a container to the helicopter during external lift training at Draughon Range near Misawa Air Base, Japan, August 21, 2017, in support of exercise Northern Viper 17.
Photo via DoD

The Marine Corps says human error caused a helicopter window to fall onto the grounds of a crowded elementary school last week on Okinawa.

The incident occurred on the morning of Dec. 13 when a CH-53E Super Stallion’s window inexplicably became separated from the aircraft and landed on Futenma Daini Elementary School’s sports field, which is adjacent to Marine Corps Air Station Futenma’s fence line. More than 50 schoolchildren were playing at the time, and one boy was slightly injured from a pebble that flew up during impact.

The 1st Marine Aircraft Wing has completed a “thorough” investigation into the incident and determined it was caused by human error, officials said a statement released Monday evening.

The window, which was not properly secured before takeoff, was designed to be removed so that the crew can evacuate during an emergency, the statement said.

Marine officials said they have conducted additional training for both air and maintenance crews to reinforce proper procedures. Also, all CH-53E aircraft have been thoroughly inspected and checked for mechanical or structural issues with the windows.

“1st MAW has taken comprehensive actions to ensure the safety of all Okinawa-based CH-53E aircraft, the aircrew that fly in them, and our broader community,” the statement said. “This incident is regrettable, and we again apologize for the anxiety it has caused the community.”

Marine officials also vowed to conduct routine maintenance days and monthly safety meetings within their squadron-level safety program.

Japanese officials weighed in on the incident earlier Monday, but were careful not to pass judgment until the results of the ongoing investigation were released.

Japan’s defense minister, Itsunori Onodera, told reporters he was waiting for sufficient safety measures to be imposed by the U.S. military.

“Safety can only be ensured when all possible measures are taken to prevent reoccurrence,” he said.

Kyodo news agency reported Monday that the service had informed Okinawa’s central and prefectural governments it planned to resume CH-53E flights “soon.”

There had been no formal announcement by the Marine Corps about grounding the Super Stallions; however, local press reported that the helicopters did not appear to be flying from Futenma after the incident.

Marine officials did not address the resumption of flights in Monday’s statement. Japan’s Ministry of Defense declined to confirm or deny the report. Okinawa prefectural officials were unavailable for comment.

Japanese Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshihide Suga told reporters Monday that Tokyo was working closely with the U.S. government and would publicize the results of the investigation once they had been digested and checked. Suga also said he urged the U.S. not to fly aircraft over hospitals and schools near Futenma.

Officials from the elementary school said Monday that Marine Corps officials had visited the school and apologized during a closed-door meeting.

The Asahi Shimbun reported that the school asked Marine officials during the meeting not to fly overhead anymore and that Marine officials said they would try their best.

The incident is the latest in a string of recent U.S. military aircraft mishaps on or around the southern Japanese island prefecture and has led to heightened safety concerns among Okinawa’s local population, simmering feelings of fear and anxiety that harken back to the days after World War II when mishaps were common and often claimed lives.

On Dec. 7, a plastic part thought to belong to a U.S. military helicopter landed on the roof of a local day care facility, leading to protests in front of U.S. military facilities.

In October, a 1st Marine Aircraft Wing Super Stallion made an emergency landing in a farmer’s field outside Okinawa’s Northern Training Area after an inflight fire. The aircraft was an almost total loss.

An MV-22 Osprey crashed last December in shallow water just off Camp Schwab, which was followed by a deadly Osprey crash in August off the coast of Australia that claimed the lives of three Marines.


©2017 the Stars and Stripes. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

U.S. Air Force/Staff Sgt. Sandra Welch

This article originally appeared on

Inside Forward Operating Base Oqab in Kabul, Afghanistan stands a wall painted with a mural of an airman kneeling before a battlefield cross. Beneath it, a black gravestone bookended with flowers and dangling dog tags displays the names of eight U.S. airmen and an American contractor killed in a horrific insider attack at Kabul International Airport in 2011.

It's one of a number of such memorials ranging from plaques, murals and concrete T-walls scattered across Afghanistan. For the last eight years, those tributes have been proof to the families of the fallen that their loved ones have not been forgotten. But with a final U.S. pullout from Afghanistan possibly imminent, those families fear the combat-zone memorials may be lost for good.

Read More Show Less
DOD photo

After a string of high profile incidents, the commander overseeing the Navy SEALs released an all hands memo stating that the elite Naval Special Warfare community has a discipline problem, and pinned the blame on those who place loyalty to their teammates over the Navy and the nation they serve.

Read More Show Less
Ed Mahoney/Kickstarter

In June 2011 Iraq's defense minister announced that U.S. troops who had deployed to the country would receive the Iraq Commitment Medal in recognition of their service. Eight years later, millions of qualified veterans have yet to receive it.

The reason: The Iraqi government has so far failed to provide the medals to the Department of Defense for approval and distribution.

A small group of veterans hopes to change that.

Read More Show Less
F-16 Fighting Falcon (Photo: US Air Force)

For a cool $8.5 million, you could be the proud owner of a "fully functioning" F-16 A/B Fighting Falcon fighter jet that a South Florida company acquired from Jordan.

The combat aircraft, which can hit a top speed of 1,357 mph at 40,000 feet, isn't showroom new — it was built in 1980. But it still has a max range of 2,400 miles and an initial climb rate of 62,000 feet per minute and remains militarized, according to The Drive, an automotive website that also covers defense topics, WBDO News 96.5 reported Wednesday.

Read More Show Less