The right way to be a military innovator

Vultures' Row
A U.S. Soldier with D Company, 1st Battalion, 3rd Aviation Regiment (Attack Reconnaissance), 12th Combat Aviation Brigade, conducts routine maintenance on a AH-64 Apache helicopter on Aug. 29, 2018, at Katterbach Army Airfield in Ansbach, Germany. The Army continues to identify ways that existing technology could be employed or re-combined to produce better products at lower cost.(Photo Credit: U.S. Army photo by Charles Rosemond)

One of the recurring complaints about the military is that it doesn't take well to new ideas. By its very nature, the military has a structure that lends itself to ideas becoming orders from the top down.

The path of least resistance is certainly to shut up and color.


It often seems the way to the top is the path of conformity and "the way we've always done it." But just as often it is actually the innovators who succeed. Those are the leaders everyone wishes they worked for. Too often, people who would be innovators either give up too early or never put the work in to see their ideas through. Then they get disillusioned and blame the system for their own failures.

It's easy to say that the time for innovation is "when I finally get promoted/get command/PCS/etc." Truth is, if you're not doing it now, you're never going to. That said, there is a fine line to be walked. No one cares about the great ideas of people who don't know anything.

A lot of those who think they are misunderstood geniuses are really just misunderstood, because they were never geniuses. The road to the top is littered with the wreckage of those who thought they were smarter than everyone else, but were really just full of problems with no solutions.

So the first step is to know your shit. Like a jazz musician, you have to know how to read music before you can improvise. A crazy idea from a shitbag is just a shitty idea. A crazy idea from a subject matter expert is innovation.

Once you know your shit, the second part is to do your homework. A lot of would-be innovators curse the darkness, yet don't realize everyone else sees it's dark too. Then they say "Why doesn't someone find the light switch?"

"Thanks. We already tried that, Mr. Edison." An actual innovator figures out how to change the light bulb and starts executing a plan. Noting problems is easy. Solving them is the hard part.

Everyone sees themselves as an "Idea" man or woman. Everyone has ideas. It's really fun looking at the big picture, but 90% of the work is in the details. If the solution is obvious, the reason it hasn't been implemented is because no one has wanted to actually do the work yet. If you want to stand out, you actually have to do the work.

The piece that everyone complains about, the "getting my boss to accept it" bit, isn't usually that bad if you've done the first two parts. Most bosses are tired of hearing complaints with no solutions. Everyone identifies problems. That's called "bitching."

Innovators figure out solutions.

There are always a few crazy or intransigent bosses who think that anything resembling change reflects poorly on them. If you truly have a toxic leader, then he or she probably isn't open to innovative solutions. That said, don't mistake a leader being idiosyncratic or not having a bubbly personality with being toxic. By the same token, plenty of outwardly friendly leaders will blow off a good idea with a smile and not even let you know it's headed for the circular file under their desks. Know your audience.

Most people are happy to reap the fruits of others' labor. If you've come with your homework complete, there's a good chance your ideas will get a fair hearing. Still, however bright you think you are, you're still in the military. The military has its traditions for a reason. You can't contradict a commander in public.

Despite what you may have heard watching "Talladega Nights," saying "With all due respect" is not a free pass to say whatever you want. There's always a right way and a wrong way, and the right way honors the chain of command.

The all-too-cliched Serenity Prayer talks about changing what one can change and knowing what one should just accept. The Secretary of Defense isn't going to take a lieutenant's point paper for action, no matter how awesome it is. But a company or battalion commander might.

Don't be discouraged because you're not changing the world. Be encouraged because you can almost certainly change your part of it.

Carl Forsling is a senior columnist for Task & Purpose. He is a Marine MV-22B pilot and former CH-46E pilot who retired from the military after 20 years of service. He is the father of two children and a graduate of Boston University and The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania. Follow him on Twitter @CarlForsling

Photo illustration by Paul Szoldra

Navy Lt. Jonny Kim went viral last week when NASA announced that he and 10 other candidates (including six other service members) became the newest members of the agency's hallowed astronaut corps. A decorated Navy SEAL and graduate of Harvard Medical School, Kim in particular seems to have a penchant for achieving people's childhood dreams.

However, Kim shared with Task & Purpose that his motivation for living life the way he has stems not so much from starry-eyed ambition, but from the pain and loss he suffered both on the battlefields of Iraq and from childhood instability while growing up in Los Angeles. Kim tells his story in the following Q&A, which was lightly edited for length and clarity:

Read More

You can almost smell the gunpowder in the scene captured by a Marine photographer over the weekend, showing a Marine grunt firing a shotgun during non-lethal weapons training.

Read More

A Marine grunt stationed in Camp Lejeune, North Carolina is being considered for an award after he saved the lives of three people earlier this month from a fiery car crash.

Cpl. Scott McDonell, an infantry assaultman with 1st Battalion, 2nd Marine Regiment, was driving down Market Street in Wilmington in the early morning hours of Jan. 11 when he saw a car on fire after it had crashed into a tree. Inside were three victims aged 17, 20, and 20.

"It was a pretty mangled wreck," McDonell told ABC 15. "The passenger was hanging out of the window."

Read More

Todd Robinson's upcoming Vietnam War drama, The Last Full Measure, is a story of two battles: One takes place during an ambush in the jungles of Vietnam in 1966, while the other unfolds more than three decades later as the survivors fight to see one pararescueman's valor posthumously recognized.

Read More
Protesters and militia fighters gather to condemn air strikes on bases belonging to Hashd al-Shaabi (paramilitary forces), outside the main gate of the U.S. Embassy in Baghdad, Iraq December 31, 2019. (Reuters/Thaier al-Sudani)

With ISIS trying to reorganize itself into an insurgency, most attacks on U.S. and allied forces in Iraq are being carried out by Shiite militias, said Air Force Maj. Gen. Alex Grynkewich, the deputy commander for operations and intelligence for U.S. troops in Iraq and Syria.

"In the time that I have been in Iraq, we've taken a couple of casualties from ISIS fighting on the ground, but most of the attacks have come from those Shia militia groups, who are launching rockets at our bases and frankly just trying to kill someone to make a point," Grynkewich said Wednesday at an event hosted by the Air Force Association's Mitchell Institute for Aerospace Studies.

Read More