What Hollywood Gets Wrong About Navy SEALs, According To 2 Former Commanders

Entertainment
Photo via Naval Special Warfare Command/DoD/FLickr

There are movies, TV shows, and video games about the U.S. Navy SEALs, and nearly all of them portray the SEALs as real-life superheroes.


This image may help draw people to Jocko Willink and Leif Babin, the former SEAL commanders behind the leadership consulting firm Echelon Front, but they're always quick to dispel the notion.

"We're not Terminators," Willink said at their two-day "Muster" conference in New York in May. Willink led Task Unit Bruiser, the most highly decorated special operations unit of the Iraq War, and Babin was his second-command as a senior platoon leader. The Muster conference was an extensive look at the principles explored in their New York Times bestseller "Extreme Ownership."

Willink explained that most civilians tend to think that SEALs, and troops in general, take orders and follow them like robots.

The reality is that SEALs may be highly trained, elite warriors, they're still human beings with human emotions. They are putting their lives and the lives of their friends on the line with every mission they take, and in a situation like that you don't quietly follow orders you disagree with.

Babin added that, "I've never seen a movie or show that's accurately captured what it's like to be in a firefight." While the superhero versions of the SEALs always seem to quickly figure out a way to pinpoint the enemy and take them out, Babin said reality is that battle is chaotic and it takes intense discipline to even figure out where the attack is coming from, let alone how to respond.

To successfully complete missions, Willink and Babin explained, SEAL commanders must create a culture where each troop takes ownership of his role in the mission and can make quick decisions when things get hectic.

Willink shared a hypothetical example of this in action:

He sets a mission for Babin and his men to secure a building and move to its roof to provide cover for another team. Babin's team gets to the roof only to see there are no protective walls, making them easy targets.

If Willink led his team poorly and Babin was just following orders, Babin would order his men to get on their bellies and would then radio Willink to see what they should do next. If Willink led his team well and Babin fully understood the mission objectives, Babin would immediately move his team off the roof and take them instead to the top floor to secure an adequate position, and then he would notify Willink of the change of plans and why they were made.

Real leadership — whether on the battlefield or in the office — is not equal to being a dictator, or assuming your troops can pull off any mission without proper guidance Willink explained. In a previous interview with Business Insider he told us, "We work with great guys, but they're humans. They're human beings. They have attitudes, they have intelligence, they have free will. And they will question your planning. They will question your ideas. And you have to not just tell them what to do. More importantly, you have to lead them. You have to explain to them this is why we're going to do this operation this way."

Afghan National Army forces go towards the site of an airplane crash in Deh Yak district of Ghazni province, Afghanistan January 27, 2020. (REUTERS/Mustafa Andaleb)

KABUL (Reuters) - At least 29 members of the Afghan security forces have been killed in Taliban attacks that followed air and ground assaults by government forces on the Islamist group at the weekend.

The surge in hostilities signals deadlock at stop-start peace talks involving U.S and Taliban negotiators in Doha. The Defense Ministry said on Sunday government forces had killed 51 Taliban fighters in the weekend assaults.

But the Taliban hit back, carrying out attacks on security checkpoints in the northern province of Kunduz on Tuesday night in which a security official who declined to be identified said 15 members of the Afghan army were killed.

Read More
Gen. Chuck Horner (ret.) commanded the air campaign of Desert Storm (Task & Purpose photo illustration)

When Air Force Gen. Chuck Horner (ret.) took to the podium at the dedication of the National Desert Storm and Desert Shield Memorial site in Washington D.C. last February, he told the audience that people often ask him why a memorial is necessary for a conflict that only lasted about 40 days.

Horner, who commanded the U.S. air campaign of that war, said the first reason is to commemorate those who died in the Gulf War. Then he pointed behind him, towards the Vietnam Veterans Memorial, where the names of over 58,000 Americans who died in Vietnam are etched in granite.

"These two monuments are inexorably linked together," Horner said. "Because we had in Desert Storm a president and a secretary of defense who did the smartest thing in the world: they gave the military a mission which could be accomplished by military force."

The Desert Storm Memorial "is a place every military person that's going to war should visit, and they learn to stand up when they have to, to avoid the stupidness that led to that disaster" in Vietnam, he added.

Now, 29 years after the operation that kicked Saddam Hussein's Iraqi army out of Kuwait began, the U.S. is stuck in multiple wars that Horner says resemble the one he and his fellow commanders tried to avoid while designing Desert Storm.

Horner shared his perspective on what went right in the Gulf War, and what's gone wrong since then, in an interview last week with Task & Purpose.

Read More
Staff Sgt. Logan Melgar (U.S. Army photo)

The Navy SEAL accused of strangling Army Special Forces Staff Sgt. Logan Melgar was promoted to chief petty officer two months after Melgar's death, according to a new report from The Daily Beast.

Read More
A C-17 Globemaster III assigned to the 911th Airlift Wing is towed across the flightline at March Air Reserve Base, California, Jan. 7, 2020. (Air Force photo by Joshua J. Seybert)

March Air Reserve Base in California will host nearly 200 U.S. citizens who were flown out of Wuhan, China due to the rapidly-spreading coronavirus, a Defense Department spokeswoman announced on Wednesday.

"March Air Reserve Base and the Department of Defense (DoD) stand ready to provide housing support to Health and Human Services (HHS) as they work to handle the arrival of nearly 200 people, including Department of State employees, dependents and U.S. citizens evacuated from Wuhan, China," said Pentagon press secretary Alyssa Farah in a statement on Wednesday.

Wuhan is the epicenter of the coronavirus, which is a mild to severe respiratory illness that's associated with symptoms of fever, cough and shortness of breath, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

The virus has so far killed 132 people and infected nearly 6,000 others in China, according to news reports.

Read More
A KC-46A Pegasus during testing with a C-5M Super Galaxy for the first time on April 29, 2019. (U.S. Air Force/Christian Turner)

Editor's Note: This article originally appeared on Business Insider.

Protracted delays on Boeing's new KC-46 tanker could leave the Pentagon with a shortage of refueling capacity, the head of U.S. Transportation Command warned on Tuesday.

Read More