How A Forward-Looking Approach To Gender Will Make The Marines Stronger

Opinion
U.S. Marine Corps Pfc. Natalie Price, center, assigned to Charlie Company, Infantry Training Battalion (ITB), School of Infantry-East, graduates ITB at Camp Geiger, N.C., April 6, 2017.
Marine Corps photo

During a recent chat with a fellow Marine, the Marines United scandal and debate about gender within the Corps inevitably came up. We’d been catching up, talking about our families and careers, but the mention of gender brought an eye-roll from our friend.


“I’m so sick of that shit,” he declared. “That has absolutely nothing to do with warfighting.” His response was unsurprising and typical of the Corps we grew up in: bold and assertive, but also ignorant. In truth, gender has a lot to do with warfighting, and approaching warfighting from a gender-relational perspective can greatly enhance both effectiveness and lethality.

Unfortunately, the Marine Corps has been predictably slow to embrace this concept.

Adopting a gender-relational perspective on warfighting is essential to the Marine Corps’ primary mission: winning the nation’s battles. This perspective involves more than just considering the capabilities women do and don’t bring to a fighting organization. Rather, it means developing an understanding of how identity contributes to organizational capacity, capability, process, and narrative, and recognizing that warfighters need a wide range of skills beyond mere physical ability.

The multi-dimensional and increasingly complex future operating environment demands a diverse skillset. By limiting our image of the ideal warfighter to the type of person who excels in the stereotypical physical domain — think square-jawed and muscle bound — while conflating “gender” with efforts to meet quotas, we overlook the force-multiplying potential of the gender-relational perspective.

The Marines of the future must possess critical thinking ability, technical expertise, mental and physical endurance, maturity, and resilience — capabilities found in men and women alike. Understanding the dynamics of gender will allow the Marine Corps to identify how to develop these skills, increasing organizational efficiency, enhancing talent management, and building organizational adaptability and flexibility.

Marine Candidates participate in a fire team assault course at the Officer Candidate School, Marine Corps Base Quantico, Virginia, June 17, 2017.Marine Corps photo

By lifting the veil around gender stereotypes, developing a gender-relational perspective will also help the Corps locate talent in unexpected places. “Man” and “woman” are not monolithic categories; even with respect to purely physical abilities, the bell curves overlap considerably. We have all known Marines who deviate from stereotypical gender roles. By basing opportunities to serve on capabilities that are typically associated with men, specifically the ability to do pull-ups, and valuing those capabilities above all else when choosing warfighters, we neglect the wide range of skills that any capable human possesses such as intellect, critical thinking skills, and social and emotional intelligence. The future battlefield will demand these kinds of skills from its leaders. A gender relational perspective can help the Corps eliminate this limitation to become a more flexible, effective, and adaptive institution that fully embraces the most valuable skills in the available talent pool.

Ultimately, this isn’t just about women, it’s about capabilities and an institution’s capacity to effectively deploy employ them. Women provide access to the female perspective inaccessible to all-male units, particularly in conflict zones where cultural norms often prevent contact with civilian by male Marines. The unique societal pressures and expectations experienced by women provide unique perspectives that allow the bridging of cultural barriers and building of trust among local populations that expand a unit’s skillset, a phenomenon cultural support teams experienced in Afghanistan. Warfighting organizations must seek every available advantage, so incorporating diverse perspectives, that meet the requirements of the complex modern battlefield, is critical.

Optics matter too. The gender composition of the Marine Corps should reflect American values to the international community. If we consider concepts like equal opportunity and human rights to be key democratic principles, then the Marine Corps should be representative these values. If not, we face the prospect of the force increasingly diverging from contemporary America: Today’s Corps is 8% female, and that percentage drops precipitously among middle and higher ranks. This kind of rift would limit the Corps’ ability to recruit and retain intelligent men and women representative of the nation they pledge to defend. Failing to project those principles overseas during joint military operations and exercises leaves the Corps looking either negligent or hypocritical.  

U.S. Marine Corps recruits with November Company, 4th Battalion and Hotel Company, 2nd Battalion, Recruit Training Regiment, maneuver through an obstacle course on Marine Corps Recruit Depot, Parris Island, S.C., May, 20, 2017.Marine Corps photo

Despite commonly held beliefs, homogenous units are far less prepared for the challenges of the future. Because Marine Corps assessments predict that future conflicts will require a greater range of unconventional, non-traditional warfighting skills, drawing from only half the population means commanders are less likely to wind up with the highly qualified Marines they need. Moreover, decision-making and leadership — skills that rely on maximizing experience  — would also suffer in an all-male force.

Facing an increasingly complex international environment, the Marine Corps must embrace every opportunity to diversify its ranks. Adopting a gender-relational perspective makes an institution more effective, flexible, and creative, and therefore, more lethal. If the Marine Corps wants to remain an exemplary fighting force — one able to seize every advantage in future conflicts — it must embrace gender diversity within its ranks.

It can see through smoke and in near total darkness, translate written foreign languages and pull up detailed maps, and can rapidly acquire and identify targets. It's the Army's new heads-up display of the future, and it's coming to an armory near you sooner than you think.

Read More Show Less

Care packages put together by First Lady Melania Trump and Second Lady Karen Pence on Wednesday could soon end up at a military base near you.

Read More Show Less

A Coast Guard seaman accused of murder was released from a San Diego brig Monday as the admiral overseeing his prosecution ordered a new hearing in the case.

Seaman Ethan W. Tucker, 21, was arrested August 28 after a seven-month Coast Guard investigation into the January death of Seaman Ethan Kelch, 19, who served on the same ship as Tucker— the Douglas Munro, a high endurance cutter based in Kodiak, Alaska.

Tucker is charged with murder, involuntary manslaughter, aggravated assault, making false official statements, obstruction of justice and failure to obey orders. He has not entered a plea and won't do so unless his case is referred to a court-martial.

Read More Show Less
Oops (Twitter)

There's something very, very wrong with a recent tweet from the official Twitter account of the Defense Department. Can you spot it?

Let's zoom in, just in case.

Read More Show Less

Two U.S. troops were killed in Afghanistan on Wednesday in a helicopter crash, military officials have announced.

Read More Show Less