Why It’s Wrong To Build A War Memorial For Operation Desert Storm

The Long March
U.S. soldiers take oath to the U.S. Army on an Iraqi destroyed tank in Iraq on February 27th, 1991.
Getty Images/Eric Bouvet/Gamma-Rapho

I didn’t realize there was a movement afoot to build a monument specifically to Operation Desert Storm, the 1991 100-hour offensive. But I just saw this article, and my initial reaction is that I viscerally dislike this idea. I have two thoughts about why:


This thing lasted a mere 100 hours. Do you want to put that alongside the World War II monument, the Vietnam Monument, and the Lincoln Memorial? Really?

It wasn’t really a war. It was an initial operation in a war that continues to this day. After ground operations ended, air operations began, as well as ground ops in the north, in “Operation Provide Comfort.” Then came more intense air ops, a couple of times, most notably in the “Desert Fox” airstrikes of 1998, in which, as I recall, more cruise missiles were fired than in “Desert Storm.” (So do we need a “Desert Fox” memorial too? Then we invaded in 2003, and we still have people there, some 15 years later.

Yes, there were casualties in “Desert Storm,” but they were a fraction of those suffered in minor Civil War actions such as, for one example, the Battle of Ezra Church. So it just seems to me disproportionate to give this op a separate monument. It also seems premature to erect a monument to a war that has not ended, and whose outcome we do not yet know.

If you insist on a memorial, maybe it should just be really small, perhaps the size of a desk. I also like @JasonKirell  ‘s suggestion that we start building a monument but never finish it.

Or maybe we could build it as a maze without an exit.

WATCH NEXT:

Soldiers from the 3d U.S. Infantry Regiment (The Old Guard) hold folded flags before military funeral honors. (U.S. Army/Elizabeth Fraser)

The Minnesota National Guard has released the names of the three soldiers killed in Thursday's helicopter crash.

Read More Show Less
The main gate at Naval Air Station Pensacola is seen on Navy Boulevard in Pensacola, Florida, U.S. March 16, 2016. Picture taken March 16, 2016. (U.S. Navy/Patrick Nichols/Handout via Reuters)

Editor's Note: This article by Richard Sisk originally appeared on Military.com, a leading source of news for the military and veteran community.

The Navy pledged Friday to find ways to upgrade security procedures and prevent future attacks following two shootings and a fatal gate runner incident at naval bases in Virginia, Hawaii and Florida in the last week.

Defense Secretary Mark Esper also announced he is "considering several steps to ensure the security of our military installations and the safety of our service members and their families," although he did not give details.

Read More Show Less
The sinking of the USS Arizona during the attack on Pearl Harbor on Dec. 7, 1941 (U.S. Navy via Assocaited Press)

Ceremonies for Pearl Harbor Day, are already under way on Oahu despite a shooting spree that left three people dead on Wednesday. Officials vow to continue with the traditional Dec. 7 Pearl Harbor commemoration.

Today we take a look at the last three survivors of the USS Arizona, which was sunk on Dec. 7, 1941.

Read More Show Less
A Purple Heart and Silver Star (Atlanta Journal-Constitution photo)

An Army veteran from Columbus claimed he suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder after a deployment in Afghanistan that earned him a Purple Heart and Silver Star.

As a result, he collected $76,000 in benefits for the mental condition.

He admitted Wednesday, however, that all of that was a lie.

He was not deployed to Afghanistan, never suffered PTSD and never received the two honors, which are among the highest bestowed for military service.

Read More Show Less
Rep. Duncan Hunter (AP Photo/Denis Poroy)

SAN DIEGO — Days after Rep. Duncan Hunter pleaded guilty to a federal felony related to a yearslong campaign finance scandal, he has finally stated explicitly that he will resign from his congressional seat before the end of his term.

"Shortly after the holidays I will resign from Congress," Hunter, R-Calif., in a statement. "It has been an honor to serve the people of California's 50th District, and I greatly appreciate the trust they have put in me over these last 11 years."

Read More Show Less