Soldier Discharged For Sexual Misconduct Hopes To Take His Case To The Supreme Court

news
Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, speaks during the keynote address or the State Bar of New Mexico's Annual Meeting in Pojoaque, N.M.,Friday, Aug. 19, 2016.
AP Photo by Craig Fritz

Djoulou K. Caldwell’s conduct at Joint Base Lewis-McChord in Washington state certainly seemed crude.


He licked his lips while “leering” at a female soldier in the 14th Engineering Battalion, the lower-ranking woman testified. He looked at her “body up and down,” she said. He assured her he could make her fall in love with him. He commented, coarsely, on her looks.

“I just wanted to see your ass when you walked out of the office,” Caldwell told the woman, she testified.

For those actions, and more, Caldwell was given a bad conduct discharge after his conviction on charges of abusive sexual contact and maltreatment of a subordinate. His last shot is a long one, as his lawyers urge the Supreme Court to hear a rare military court challenge.

“The (case) has the potential to impact the over-1,300,000 men and women actively serving in the United States armed forces,” Caldwell’s attorneys wrote in a petition filed this month, adding that “this is an issue that is central to hundreds of convictions for maltreatment in recent years.”

Caldwell’s petition joins a handful of other military cases seeking Supreme Court attention. Perhaps most prominently, several military justice groups are urging the court to consider a death penalty challenge by University of California, Davis graduate Hasan K. Akbar, convicted of killing two fellow soldiers in Kuwait in 2003.

While each case may seem compelling in its own way, the Supreme Court infrequently second-guesses military justice.

RELATED: This soldier stood up to sexual harassment. Then she was kicked out of the Army »

“It’s very difficult to convince the Supreme Court to take these cases,” Eugene R. Fidell, a military law specialist who teaches at Yale Law School, said in an interview. “The justices are gun-shy about getting involved.”

Beyond the unique military issues, few challenges of any kind make it into the Supreme Court’s chambers. The court receives upward of 9,000 petitions annually, and typically grants oral argument and full consideration to only about 75.

The court’s eight current members are scheduled to review Akbar’s petition on Sept. 26, along with a separate challenge from a now-retired Coast Guard captain convicted of cocaine use.

Fidell is representing that veteran of more than 27 years service, whose trial judge had personal and professional relationships with “a significant number of the court-martial participants,” an appeals court stated.

Caldwell’s challenge to his May 2014 conviction centers on a 2015 Supreme Court decision reversing the conviction of a Pennsylvania man who posted threatening-sounding statements on Facebook. The man, Anthony Douglas Elonis, contended his posts were no more than “fictitious lyrics,” akin to rap music.

In a 7-2 decision, the high court said that the “defendant’s mental state” must be taken into account and that “wrongdoing must be conscious to be criminal.” That effectively raised the bar for prosecutors, and Caldwell’s attorneys now say the panel of officers and enlisted personnel who convicted him didn’t apply this standard.

Put another way, Caldwell could be suggesting that he considered his behavior as flirtatious banter rather than conscious maltreatment of a subordinate.

“What Sgt. Caldwell thinks does matter,” Army Capt. Scott A. Martin told the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces in oral arguments last February.

The five-member military appeals court didn’t buy it, unanimously upholding Caldwell’s conviction and noting “the unique nature of the offense of maltreatment in the military.”

Government attorneys added, in their own brief, that Caldwell’s actions extended over a period of many months both in Washington state and after the engineering battalion was deployed on its fourth combat tour from 2011 through 2012 to Afghanistan.

“I was shocked and I guess a little intimidated just because he was a senior NCO,” recounted the woman, identified only as CH.

Army Capt. Scott L. Goble, a Texas Tech and Texas A&M; graduate representing the government, likewise cited during the earlier oral argument the “character of the military environment.”

“The very nature of the superior-subordinate relationship makes this case different,” Goble said, citing the need to “maintain good order and discipline.”

———

© 2016 McClatchy Washington Bureau. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

The Pentagon has identified the two soldiers were killed in combat in Afghanistan on Wednesday as members of U.S. Army Special Forces.

Master Sgt. Luis F. DeLeon-Figueroa, 31, and Master Sgt. Jose J. Gonzalez, 35, both died in Faryab Province from wounds sustained from small arms fire, the Pentagon said in a press release. The incident is under investigation.

Read More Show Less

JERUSALEM (Reuters) - Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu hinted on Thursday of possible Israeli involvement in attacks against Iranian-linked targets in Iraq.

A series of blasts in the past few weeks have hit weapon depots and bases belonging to paramilitary groups in Iraq, many of them backed by Israel's regional foe Iran. The groups blamed the United States and Israel for the blasts on Wednesday.

Read More Show Less
White House/Shealah Craighead

President Donald Trump signed an executive order on Wednesday that will make it easier for permanently disabled veterans to have their student loan debt forgiven.

Read More Show Less
Capt. Tranay Lashawn Tanner. (U.S. Air Force photo)

Editor's Note: This article by Oriana Pawlyk originally appeared on Military.com, a leading source of news for the military and veteran community.

Physical fitness tests were briefly suspended earlier this week and outdoor cardio testing will be curtailed for the remainder of the summer at Eglin Air Force Base, Florida, after an airman died Saturday. She had completed her PT test on Friday.

Read More Show Less
(DoD photo)

Navy Secretary Richard Spencer has expanded a review of the Judge Advocate General Corps to include the Marine Corps, a Navy spokesman said on Thursday.

"There is value in applying this review and its subsequent recommendations across the Department of the Navy," Cmdr. Jereal Dorsey told Task & Purpose. "The review's purpose is to confirm the uniformed legal community is structurally and organizationally sound and best supporting the good order and discipline our integrated naval force."

Read More Show Less