Trump's 'maximum pressure' on foreign adversaries has hit its limit


WASHINGTON — In two years as president, Donald Trump built a foreign policy strategy on applying as much pressure as possible on enemies — and even some allies — to make them bend to America's will.

Venezuela, North Korea and Iran have all been targets of the administration's "maximum pressure" approach. Under Trump, U.S. sanctions were deployed to notable effect: Venezuela's battered economy is more isolated than ever, Iran has seen oil sales plummet and North Korea has struggled as fuel and electricity shortages crimp output and food shortages loom.

Yet no adversary has buckled. So, short of war, what does the U.S. do now?

"As a great power, the United States does have a lot of options," said Jonathan Alterman, director of the Middle East Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. "At the same time, though, other countries have lots of options, too, and the administration sometimes seems surprised that they are not merely submitting to superior U.S. power."

The challenge the U.S. faces, and the loneliness of its campaign, were on display during Secretary of State Michael Pompeo's hastily scheduled stop in Brussels this week, when he met with the foreign ministers of the U.K., France and Germany to underscore the urgency of the threat posed by Iran. But European leaders openly expressed their exasperation with the U.S. approach to Iran.

"I have to say that this is a distressful example of U.S. unilateralism — it is short-term and inconsiderate of interests" of some of its closest allies, Germany's Deputy Foreign Minister, Niels Annen, said afterward during a speech in Berlin. "The current situation in the region, ladies and gentlemen, is extremely dangerous."

Annen's remarks reflected how U.S. goals have been tripped up by its consistent use of strong-arm tactics with nations whose support it later needs to box in its adversaries. Allies such as Canada, France, the U.K., Mexico and Germany have all come in for withering public criticism for not bending to U.S. requests on key issues — only to be courted on others.

One senior administration official, who asked not to be identified discussing internal matters, said there were two ways to read the Europeans' response in Brussels: Either they don't believe the U.S. assessment of the new threats from Iran and want to tame the administration's impulses. Or the situation is just the opposite: They believe the threats but don't want to publicly admit it, for fear of giving momentum to a potential military confrontation.

Three days after Pompeo's visit, Britain's foreign secretary, Jeremy Hunt, tweeted: "We share the same assessment of the heightened threat posed by Iran."

While Trump has said he's optimistic that "Iran will want to talk soon," his national security adviser, John Bolton, has advocated regime change and even preemptive strikes against Tehran for years.

Pompeo, a former CIA director, is also seen as a hard-liner on the Islamic Republic, although he's said his goal isn't to seek a war with Iran or impose regime change from outside. His advisers argue that the maximum-pressure campaign already has limited Iran's ability to wreak havoc in the region.

"If you look at 40 years of this regime, they change their behavior when one or more of these elements are present: economic pressure, diplomatic isolation and the threat of military force," Brian Hook, Pompeo's special envoy on Iran, said of the government in Tehran. "We think this is the right approach."

In Tehran, officials say they won't negotiate under duress. And without a functioning diplomatic back channel, it's not clear how talks would even be initiated.

"Nobody is going to call Trump, and eventually the Americans will be forced to raise the issue of negotiations with Iran in a serious way," Heshmatollah Falahatpishe, the head of Iran's parliamentary commission for national security and foreign affairs, said in a speech before his nation's lawmakers, according to the Islamic Students' News Agency.

North Korea policy also appears at a stalemate. Tensions were raised between the two countries in 2017, when Pyongyang was undertaking a series of nuclear and missile tests and Trump responded by threatening to rain down "fire and fury" on Kim Jong Un's regime. He reversed course quickly, however, to open talks and offer effusive praise for the North Korean dictator, even saying they "fell in love."

Yet little has been accomplished diplomatically: Pyongyang is further along in its weapons program and there's no clear path toward the denuclearization Trump's team says is its goal. One victory the U.S. has touted — a suspension of major missile and weapons tests — is teetering. Earlier this month North Korea held two separate rounds of short-range missile tests that are barred under United Nations sanctions, leading even Trump to scale back his previously optimistic tone about the talks.

"Nobody's happy about it," Trump told reporters last week. "I don't think they're ready to negotiate."

The risk for Trump and the world is greatest now over Iran. Even with both sides saying they don't want war, analysts flag the risk of an accident or unintended clash turning into something larger.

"Brinkmanship with Iran could quite easily backfire," said Paul Sullivan, a Middle East expert at Georgetown University's Center for Security Studies. "Batting mosquitoes with sledge hammers can be very costly for the batter, not just the mosquitoes."


©2019 Bloomberg News. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

SEE ALSO: No, The Pentagon's 'New' Aircraft Carrier And Bomber Deployment Is Not A Sign Of Imminent War With Iran

WATCH NEXT: Gen. Petraeus On Shia Militias And Iran

President Donald Trump speaks about American missile defense doctrine, Thursday, Jan 17, 2019, at the Pentagon. (Associated Press/Evan Vucci)

GENEVA/DUBAI (Reuters) - U.S. President Donald Trump said he was prepared to take military action to stop Tehran from getting a nuclear bomb but left open whether he would back the use of force to protect Gulf oil supplies that Washington fears may be under threat by Iran.

Worries about a confrontation between Iran and the United States have mounted since attacks last week on two oil tankers near the strategic Strait of Hormuz shipping lane at the entrance to the Gulf. Washington blamed long-time foe Iran for the incidents.

Tehran denies responsibility but the attacks, and similar ones in May, have further soured relations that have plummeted since Trump pulled the United States out of a landmark international nuclear deal with Iran in May 2018.

Trump has restored and extended U.S. economic sanctions on Iran. That has forced countries around the world to boycott Iranian oil or face sanctions of their own.

But in an interview with Time magazine, Trump, striking a different tone from some Republican lawmakers who have urged a military approach to Iran, said last week's tanker attacks in the Gulf of Oman had only a "very minor" impact so far.

Asked if he would consider military action to prevent Iran from obtaining nuclear weapons or to ensure the free flow of oil through the Gulf, Trump said: "I would certainly go over nuclear weapons and I would keep the other a question mark."

Read More Show Less
(Lockheed Martin photo)

Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz said Tuesday he is appalled by a state DFL Party staff member's tweet referring to the recently-launched USS Minneapolis-Saint Paul as a "murder boat."

"Certainly, the disrespect shown is beyond the pale," said Walz, who served in the Army National Guard.

William Davis, who has been the DFL Party's research director and deputy communications director, made the controversial comment in response to a tweet about the launch of a new Navy combat ship in Wisconsin: "But actually, I think it's gross they're using the name of our fine cities for a murder boat," Davis wrote on Twitter over the weekend.

Read More Show Less
(U.S. Air Force/TSgt. Dana Flamer)

TAMPA — Minutes before the Acting Secretary of Defense withdrew Tuesday from his confirmation process, U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo spoke at MacDill Air Force Base about the need to coordinate "diplomatic and defense efforts'' to address rising tensions with Iran.

Pompeo, who arrived in Tampa on Monday, met with Marine Gen. Kenneth McKenzie Jr. and Army Gen. Richard Clarke, commanders of U.S. Central Command and U.S. Special Operations Command respectively, to align the Government's efforts in the Middle East, according to Central Command.

Read More Show Less
Paul Szoldra/Task & Purpose

NAVAL BASE SAN DIEGO — The trial of Navy SEAL Chief Eddie Gallagher officially kicked off on Tuesday with the completion of jury selection, opening statements, and witness testimony indicating that drinking alcohol on the front lines of Mosul, Iraq in 2017 seemed to be a common occurrence for members of SEAL Team 7 Alpha Platoon.

Government prosecutors characterized Gallagher as a knife-wielding murderer who not only killed a wounded ISIS fighter but shot indiscriminately at innocent civilians, while the defense argued that those allegations were falsehoods spread by Gallagher's angry subordinates, with attorney Tim Parlatore telling the jury that "this trial is not about murder. It's about mutiny."

Read More Show Less

President Donald Trump announced on Tuesday that Acting Defense Secretary Patrick Shanahan will "not to go forward with his confirmation process."

Trump said that Army Secretary Mark Esper will now serve as acting defense secretary.

Read More Show Less