Trump's 'red flags' on Mattis included 'controversial statements' and alleged leniency on war crimes


Then-Secretary of Defense James N. Mattis

(DoD/Sgt. Amber I. Smith)

President Donald Trump may have loved to call former Secretary of Defense James Mattis by his much-loathed "Mad Dog" nickname, but his own transition team had concerns regarding the former Marine general's infamous battlefield missives and his lackluster handling of alleged war crimes committed by U.S. service members, according to leaked vetting documents.

The vetting documents, published by Axios on Sunday, detail the Trump transition team's research into dozens of candidates for cabinet and senior administration positions, which included "red flags" for Mattis, disgraced CIA director David Petraeus, and future Department of Homeland Security boss and White House Chief of Staff John Kelly.

According to Axios, Trump "reviewed many of these documents at Trump Tower and Bedminster before his interviews, according to a source who saw him eyeball them."

While Petraeus' vetting documents centered on his relative opposition to torture, among other issues, the primary red flags for Mattis include his history of "controversial statements" stretching all the way back Mattis' time as a Marine Corps three-star who led U.S. forces in Iraq and Afghanistan and his 2013 "attack" on the U.S. for "for a perceived pro-Israel bias."

But among the most interesting concerns of Trump transition officials is the fact that Mattis "was relatively lenient in dealing with soldiers accused of war crimes," which includes a redacted section:

The 2007 dismissal of charges is in reference to Mattis, then the commander of the I Marine Expeditionary Force, for its role as convening authority in the case of the 2005 Haditha massacre, in which several Marines allegedly massacred 24 Iraqi civilians.

As Task & Purpose previously reported, the Haditha massacre was the biggest war crimes case since the My Lai massacre during the Vietnam War, but Mattis dismissed charges against two Marines and granted immunity to a total of four, effectively shielding them from court-martial proceedings and detailing his logic in a letter to one of the accused. Here's how T&P's Adam Linehan described the letter in his May 2018 investigation into the Haditha saga:

Over four paragraphs of florid prose, the author's tone veered from pensive — "the experience of combat is difficult to understand intellectually and very difficult to appreciate emotionally" — to cryptic — "our way is right, but it is also difficult." It noted affectionately that "the challenges of this combat environment put extreme pressures on you." And it even invoked Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr., "one of our Nation's most articulate Supreme Court Justices," affirming that "detached reflection cannot be demanded in the face of an uplifted knife."

The letter, which was soon leaked, seemed to have been written with a broader audience in mind. "You have served as a Marine infantryman in Iraq where our Nation is fighting a shadowy enemy who hides among the innocent people, does not comply with any aspect of the law of war, and routinely targets and intentionally draws fire toward civilians," it stated. And it concluded, "With this dismissal of charges, you remain in the eyes of the law — and in my eyes — innocent."

It was almost as if the author had been speaking on behalf of the Marine Corps as a whole, defending its honor at a moment of profound crisis and making the case for the moral rightness of its mission in the grim shadow not only of Haditha's horrors but of Fallujah's as well. And it was signed J.N. Mattis.

This philosophy of "moral righteousness" may have been seen as a weakness to Trump transition staffers, but Trump himself clearly doesn't see it that way. In fact, Trump has recentlly shown an unusual willingness to use his executive power to pardon U.S. service members and veterans both accused and convicted of war crimes.

In May alone, Trump pardoned Army Lt. Michael Behenna, who was imprisoned for five years for killing an Iraqi prisoner in 2008, and was actively considering the possibility of issuing pardons for Navy SEAL Chief Edward Gallagher and Army Special Forces Maj. Matthew Golsteyn, both of whom he had previously expressed sympathy for on Twitter.

According to a poll from the 2018 Clarion Project, 77 percent of Americans believed U.S. service members shouldn't be prosecuted for overseas war crimes simply because "war is a stressful situation and allowances should be made."

"It's kind of like the equivalent of dropping a soda can into canyon and putting on a blindfold and going and finding it, because you can't just look down and see it," diver Jeff Goodreau said of finding the wreck.

The USS Eagle 56 was only five miles off the coast of Maine when it exploded.

The World War I-era patrol boat split in half, then slipped beneath the surface of the North Atlantic. The Eagle 56 had been carrying a crew of 62. Rescuers pulled 13 survivors from the water that day. It was April 23, 1945, just two weeks before the surrender of Nazi Germany.

The U.S. Navy classified the disaster as an accident, attributing the sinking to a blast in the boiler room. In 2001, that ruling was changed to reflect the sinking as a deliberate act of war, perpetuated by German submarine U-853, a u-boat belonging to Nazi Germany's Kriegsmarine.

Still, despite the Navy's effort to clarify the circumstances surrounding the sinking, the Eagle 56 lingered as a mystery. The ship had sunk relatively close to shore, but efforts to locate the wreck were futile for decades. No one could find the Eagle 56, a small patrol ship that had come so close to making it back home.

Then, a group of friends and amateur divers decided to try to find the wreck in 2014. After years of fruitless dives and intensive research, New England-based Nomad Exploration Team successfully located the Eagle 56 in June 2018.

Business Insider spoke to two crew members — meat truck driver Jeff Goodreau and Massachusetts Department of Corrections officer Donald Ferrara — about their discovery.

Read More Show Less
(CIA photo)

Before the 5th Special Forces Group's Operational Detachment Alpha 595, before 160th Special Operations Aviation Regiment's MH-47E Chinooks, and before the Air Force combat controllers, there were a handful of CIA officers and a buttload of cash.

Read More Show Less

The last time the world saw Marine veteran Austin Tice, he had been taken prisoner by armed men. It was unclear whether his captors were jihadists or allies of Syrian dictator Bashar al Assad who were disguised as Islamic radicals.

Blindfolded and nearly out of breath, Tice spoke in Arabic before breaking into English:"Oh Jesus. Oh Jesus."

That was from a video posted on YouTube on Sept. 26, 2012, several weeks after Tice went missing near Damascus, Syria, while working as a freelance journalist for McClatchy and the Washington Post.

Now that Tice has been held in captivity for more than seven years, reporters who have regular access to President Donald Trump need to start asking him how he is going to bring Tice home.

Read More Show Less

"Shoots like a carbine, holsters like a pistol." That's the pitch behind the new Flux Defense system designed to transform the Army's brand new sidearm into a personal defense weapon.

Read More Show Less

Sometimes a joke just doesn't work.

For example, the Defense Visual Information Distribution Service tweeted and subsequently deleted a Gilbert Gottfried-esque misfire about the "Storm Area 51" movement.

On Friday DVIDSHUB tweeted a picture of a B-2 bomber on the flight line with a formation of airmen in front of it along with the caption: "The last thing #Millenials will see if they attempt the #area51raid today."

Read More Show Less