Get Task & Purpose in your inbox
A recent Task & Purpose article mentions the “trusty" e-tool among various “vet-tested” gear items for peacetime hiking. Without making too much of a casual gear recommendation, it is worth asking if the just over two-pound e-tool (without case) is too much tool for a peacetime camping trip while considering its effectiveness as an actual wartime “entrenching” tool. Do you really know your e-tool as well as you think you do?
First, it’s worth noting that there is no need to bring along stuff just because you got it from the military—it’s finally your own pack and your very own Mission Essential Equipment List. Getting out into nature on a peacetime backpacking trip can be great for the soul, even fun, especially particularly if you intend just a walk in the sun. Put in the trauma dressing, sure; it’s very light and stuff happens. But think about everything else and why it is worth carrying that weight.
Now the real question: Why do you need to pack a digging tool in the backcountry? If the principal reason is your need to dig a cathole latrine, think about getting one of those polycarbonate trowels for five bucks that only weigh three ounces. The tools are more than capable for a cathole or a drain channel around your tent and are virtually impossible to lose in their near-fluorescent colors. If you think you need a pounding option, you might consider the cornucopia of rocks usually available on-site; if you think you need something for cutting trees, the park ranger would prefer you leave it in the car. An e-tool will work, but it’s probably more tool and more weight than required.
So why is the e-tool so essential for wartime entrenching? Well, e-tools originated to scrape a bit of hasty cover while prone under fire, and for that, it is as good as any other handheld shovel. But the e-tool is more often used for larger holes while not under direct fire. In the first stage of turning a hasty position into a two-person infantry fighting position, each soldier’s share of the excavation is roughly 30 cubic feet. This is about 300 times the volume of a cathole. Is the e-tool really up to this bigger job?
I do not claim experience with the current tool, but I had a close relationship with a Model 1951 entrenching tool that added a short pick point to the World War II-era folding tool that brought its weight up to three pounds without the case — and I can tell you that anyone who has dug foxholes or infantry fighting positions with any e-tool has probably learned similar lessons, all of them are sad.
U.S. Navy/Mass Communications Specialist 2nd Class Michael LindseyBuilder 1st Class Robert Burke, a Seabee assigned to Naval Mobile Construction Battalion 74, uses his entrenching tool to dig a hasty fighting position during their battalion’s Field Training Exercise conducted on Camp Shelby, Miss.
In digging with an e-tool, diggers reproduce, as closely as they can, swinging a pick to break up the soil and then using a shovel to remove the loosened dirt. The small tools force contortions on full-size people just to bring the tool in contact with the ground, the tools are lousy at breaking up the soil, cutting roots or moving rocks, fragile when swung with power as a pick, and hold little soil when used as a shovel. This is no way to dig out 30 cubic feet.
The requirement for the Infantry Fighting Position, sometimes called the DePuy Fighting Hole, came from General William DePuy’s vision of future war with the Soviet Army. Army Training and Doctrine Command Bulletin 9 of 1977, the Infantry Fighting Position, explains its rich doctrinal and empirical background. It is clear DePuy knew digging such positions would need more than e-tools: When he commanded 1st Infantry Division in Vietnam, he ordered digging in along the same lines he would later make doctrine at TRADOC. To make sure his orders could be carried out, he had helicopters deliver picks, axes, d-handle shovels, and saws. Getting appropriate tools to the troops was always accepted as part of the task.
Operations since 2001 have not emphasized the features DePuy saw as the future of war against large and capable Soviet forces. But should we see them now in a new vision of future war that includes the possibility of war with Russia? Maybe today’s vision doesn’t need any holes, maybe it’s just all big ideas, AI, all-seeing surveillance and death rays, but Army Chief of Staff General Mark A. Milley’s future vision has grim undertones that suggest holes, real holes, still have a martial future.
In that case, the Army should think how it gets real tools into the hands of soldiers. For soldiers carried in future Strykers or infantry fighting vehicles, the simplest way might be to expand the vehicle’s pioneer toolset (now usually one shovel, one pick, and one ax, all full-size). What about infantry without vehicles? If General Milley’s vision comes true we can be sure helos will not be delivering them. If one of the robot pack mule projects is ever successful, a load of picks and shovels might be a worthwhile high-priority cargo.
So, we generally trust the e-tool, perhaps uncritically. But in a peacetime hike, we might only need a polycarbonate trowel. In a future war, we might really need full-size picks and shovels. However ingeniously designed, two pounds of metal origami cannot replace a full-size pick and a shovel.
James T. Quinlivan joined the nonprofit, nonpartisan RAND Corporation in 1979. He came from aerospace where he was a system engineer working on missile and classified projects. At RAND, he was a program director in Project AIR FORCE. He was later Vice President of the Army Research Division and Director of the Arroyo Center. He has published in journals including Parameters, International Security, and Marine Corps Gazette. He served with the U.S. Army in Vietnam.
An Oregon Air Guard F-15 reportedly took a million-dollar munitions dump before an emergency landing
Several hundred U.S. troops will remain in Syria after allied forces clear ISIS fighters out of their last stronghold in the country, officials said on Friday.
President Donald Trump announced in December that he would withdraw all U.S. troops from Syria, but Sen. Lindsey Graham has since made a strong push to keep a small residual force along the Turkish border along with troops from European allies.
Former Navy SEAL arrested on weapons charges in Haiti says he was doing security work tied to Haiti's president
The former Navy SEAL among a group of eight men arrested earlier this week in Port-au-Prince on weapons charges says he was providing security work "for people who are directly connected to the current President" of Haiti.
"We were being used as pawns in a public fight between him and the current Prime Minister of Haiti," said Chris Osman, 44, in a post on Instagram Friday. "We were not released we were in fact rescued."
The untold story of the dapper Marine who became the Greatest Generation's 'distracted boyfriend' meme
It's a photo for the ages: a Marine NCO, a Greek god in his dress blues, catches the eye of a lovely young woman as her boyfriend urges her on in distress. It's the photographic ancestor of the much-loved "distracted boyfriend" stock photo meme, made even sweeter by the fact that this is clearly a sailor about to lose his girl to a Devil Dog.
Well, this photo and the Marine in it, which hopscotched around Marine Corps Facebook and Instagram pages before skyrocketing to the front page of Reddit on Thursday, are very real.
The photo shows then-Staff Sgt. Louis A. Capozzoli — and he is absolutely not on his way to steal your girl.