Suicide Is More Than Just A Veteran Problem

Support
A group of veterans and supporters march from the steps of the Legislative Building for a Twenty22Many rally, Wednesday, July 22, 2015, in Olympia, Washington.
Steve Bloom/The Olympian via AP

No number is as wrought with consequence in the veterans community as 22, which has become a rallying cry for a wide range of groups and concerned individuals seeking to reduce the daily veteran suicide rate. At the same time, no number is so misleading or misunderstood.


Now veterans have a reason to look beyond 22, to a new number: 24.

On April 22, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's National Center for Health Statistics released a new study that reinforces that the suicide crisis in America is not limited to veterans. Over the last 15 years, researchers found, the national suicide rate has risen by 24%, surging across nearly every age group and demographic. In 2014 alone, 42,773 Americans died by suicide.

Related: The truth about 22 veterans a day »

"Suicide is not just a mental health issue," one CDC scientist told the Huffington Post, "it is a public health issue, and it is preventable."

To prevent suicide most effectively, it must be discussed and treated holistically, not partitioned within subsets of the population.

In the context of these new findings, it is important to remember three important things about veteran suicide:

Context matters.

The new CDC study shows that suicide is most common among middle-aged white men. VA research has found the same to be true in the veterans community.

This data point highlights a significant weaknesses in efforts to prevent veteran suicide: Much of the conversation has focused on post-9/11 veterans; even with a spike in recent years, post-9/11 veterans clearly account for a relatively small percentage of veteran suicides.

Yet because the majority of campaigns and initiatives to address veteran suicide are run by post-9/11 veterans, they invariably are designed and promoted in ways that reach post-9/11 veterans. A review of the websites of several groups working to prevent veteran suicide — such as 22KILL, Mission 22, Stop Soldier Suicide and the National Veterans Foundation — show that they do not effectively explain which veterans are dying by suicide, and commonly utilize photos of younger veterans as visual illustrations.

Non-veterans would be excused for thinking that the veteran suicide is largely a result of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. That assumption can lead to policy prescriptions that don’t actually get to the core of the veteran suicide problem.

One number won't help.

By focusing on 22 — a single, clean number — and attempting to give it the ice bucket challenge treatment, some activists are oversimplifying the issue and encouraging magical thinking.

The authors of the 2012 VA report that generated the estimate of 22 veteran suicides per day warned, "estimates of the number of Veterans who have died from suicide each day based on proxy report of history of U.S. military service should be interpreted with caution.” Co-author Robert Bossarte, head of the VA Office of Public Health’s epidemiology program, later said, "It’s not that I oppose the number 22 but it’s frequently not contextualized. So we focus on that number rather than what’s really happening within that number."

The VA is conducting new research that will hopefully lead to more precise estimates, yet reshaping public awareness will be more difficult now that 22 has taken on totemic importance.

Veteran suicide is American suicide.

No one benefits when we treat veteran suicide differently from the American suicide crisis. As noted previously, there are strong commonalities linking middle-aged Americans — veteran or not — when it comes to suicide. Suicide by Americans in their 40s, 50s and 60s, research has found, is closely linked to rising distress about jobs and personal finances, issues that have little to do with a history of military service.

Even as veteran advocates worry about the supposed 22 veteran suicides per day, the VA's 2012 report found that veteran suicide rates had remained constant or decreased slightly in the states studied, while civilian suicide rates were clearly increasing, an assertion borne out more recently by the CDC.

It’s time to recognize and appreciate that suicide is a national problem. Many triggers of suicidal ideation and action are results of life in America, not life at war, and cannot be addressed solely through veteran-focused initiatives.

Veteran suicide — and service member suicide — is a very real and enduring problem. Veterans do die by suicide at higher rates than non-veterans, and recent research found that suicidal thinking is depressingly common among veterans.

A move to shift the discussion away from a fixation with 22 and place veteran suicide within the context of a broader American problem does not require a move away from solutions veterans have already created to support their brothers and sisters in arms. Formal and informal support networks — when combined with access to professional services and treatment — are invaluable safety nets for ensuring that troubled veterans have people looking out for them.

Americans who have been to war and Americans who have never left their city of birth are taking their lives at unacceptable rates. The CDC report reinforces that veteran suicide is not an unique phenomenon, and should not be viewed through a different lens than civilian suicide.

Soldiers from the 1-118th Field Artillery Regiment of the 48th Infantry Brigade Combat Team fire an M777 Howitzer during a fire mission in Southern Afghanistan, June 10th, 2019. (U.S. Army photo by Sgt. Jordan Trent)

Once again, the United States and the Taliban are apparently close to striking a peace deal. Such a peace agreement has been rumored to be in the works longer than the latest "Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure" sequel. (The difference is Keanu Reeves has fewer f**ks to give than U.S. Special Representative for Afghanistan Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad.)

Both sides appeared to be close to reaching an agreement in September until the Taliban took credit for an attack that killed Army Sgt. 1st Class Elis A. Barreto Ortiz, of the 3rd Brigade Combat Team, 82nd Airborne Division. That prompted President Donald Trump to angrily cancel a planned summit with the Taliban that had been scheduled to take place at Camp David, Maryland, on Sept. 8.

Now Taliban spokesman Suhail Shaheen has told a Pakistani newspaper that he is "optimistic" that the Taliban could reach an agreement with U.S. negotiators by the end of January.

Read More
Audie Murphy (U.S. Army photo)

Editor's note: a version of this post first appeared in 2018

On January 26, 1945, the most decorated U.S. service member of World War II earned his legacy in a fiery fashion.

Read More
A Purple Heart (DoD photo)

Florida's two senators are pushing the Defense Department to award Purple Hearts to the U.S. service members wounded in the December shooting at Naval Air Station Pensacola.

Read More
Ships from Destroyer Squadron (DESRON) 23 transit the Pacific Ocean Jan. 22, 2020. DESRON 23, part of the Theodore Roosevelt Carrier Strike Group, is on a scheduled deployment to the Indo-Pacific. (U.S. Navy/Mass Communication Specialist 3rd Class Erick A. Parsons)

Editor's Note: This article by Gina Harkins originally appeared on Military.com, a leading source of news for the military and veteran community.

The Navy and Marine Corps need to be a bit more short-sighted when assessing how many ships they need, the acting Navy secretary said this week.

The Navy Department is in the middle of a new force-structure review, which could change the number and types of ships the sea services say they'll need to fight future conflicts. But instead of trying to project what they will need three decades out, which has been the case in past assessments, acting Navy Secretary Thomas Modly said the services will take a shorter view.

"I don't know what the threat's going to be 30 years from now, but if we're building a force structure for 30 years from now, I would suggest we're probably not building the right one," he said Friday at a National Defense Industrial Association event.

The Navy completed its last force-structure assessment in 2016. That 30-year plan called for a 355-ship fleet.

Read More
Master-at-Arms 3rd Class Oscar Temores and his family. (GoFundMe)

When Oscar Jesus Temores showed up to work at Joint Expeditionary Base Little Creek-Fort Story each day, his colleagues in base security knew they were in for a treat.

Temores was a master-at-arms who loved his job and cracking corny jokes.

"He just he just had that personality that you can go up to him and talk to him about anything. It was goofy and weird, and he always had jokes," said Petty Officer 3rd Class Derek Lopez, a fellow base patrolman. "Sometimes he'd make you cry from laughter and other times you'd just want to cringe because of how dumb his joke was. But that's what made him more approachable and easy to be around."

That ability to make others laugh and put people at ease is just one of the ways Temores is remembered by his colleagues. It has been seven weeks since the 23-year-old married father of one was killed when a civilian intruder crashed his pickup truck into Temores' vehicle at Fort Story.

Read More