Commandant says Marines should have a say in whether they change duty stations

U.S. Marine Corps Gen. Eric M. Smith speaks during a Relinquishment of Office ceremony at Marine Barracks Washington, D.C. on July 10, 2023. The 38th Commandant of the Marine Corps, Gen. David H. Berger, relinquished the office to Assistant Commandant of the Marine Corps Gen. Eric M. Smith. Until a new Commandant is confirmed by the Senate and appointed to the position, Gen. Smith will be the acting Commandant, retaining the title and position of Assistant Commandant of the Marine Corps. (U.S. Marine Corps photo by Staff Sgt. Kelsey Dornfeld)
Marines typically move every three years, but they should be able to stay where they are for up to 12 years, the Marine Corps commandant says. Marine Corps photo by Staff Sgt. Kelsey Dornfeld.

Marines who want to stay at their current duty stations should be able to do so instead of being forced to make a permanent change of station, or PCS move every few years, Marine Corps Commandant Gen. Eric Smith said on Thursday.

“We have to let Marines pick their own duty station,” Smith said during the annual Modern Day Marine exhibition in Washington, D.C. “If you let a Marine write his own tasking statement, he’ll get it right 100% of the time.”

Smith was not announcing any new policy change, rather, he was speaking about the Marine Corps’ ongoing efforts to refine its talent management process, a Marine Corps official told Task & Purpose.

The commandant’s comments came in response to a question about what the Marine Corps is doing to recruit and retain Marines.

“You can’t recruit your way out of a manpower crisis, you can only retain your way out,” Smith said.

Smith spoke about how some Marines should be able to stay where they are currently assigned if it helps their careers and family life.

“If a Marine is at Camp Lejeune, [North Carolina] and they want to stay at Camp Lejeune for nine years or 12 years, that’s fine by me,” Smith said. “Why do I have to move him to Camp Pendleton, [California]? Well, because that’s what we do as Marines: We move every three years. Well why? Because that’s what we do. Well why? Because that’s what we do. Well why? I mean, it doesn’t make any sense to me.”

“If you want to stay at Camp Pendleton, your spouse has good employment, you’re happy in your home there, and you know the terrain and you know the training, why can’t you stay there for nine, or 10 or 12 years?” he continued. “I’m not saying you should stay there for your entire 30-year career, but we don’t have to move you every three years.” 

The Marines have done better than most of the other military branches on recruiting in recent years. In February, Marine Corps Recruiting Command spokesman Jim Edwards told Task & Purpose that the Marines are on track to meet their recruiting goal for this fiscal year, as they have for decades.

One reason why the Marine Corps has been able to meet its recruiting goals for so many years is that it holds recruiters who don’t make their mission accountable, and that includes relieving them, Smith said on Thursday.

“My own son is an officer recruiter, and he knows that if he doesn’t make mission, he doesn’t get to come home for Christmas,” Smith said. “I’m only a little bit joking about that.”

The latest on Task & Purpose

 

Task & Purpose Video

Each week on Tuesdays and Fridays our team will bring you analysis of military tech, tactics, and doctrine.

 
Jeff Schogol Avatar

Jeff Schogol

Senior Pentagon Reporter

Jeff Schogol is a senior staff writer for Task & Purpose. He has covered the military for nearly 20 years. Email him at schogol@taskandpurpose.com; direct message @JSchogol73030 on Twitter; or reach him on WhatsApp and Signal at 703-909-6488.