A San Diego man bilked $30 million out of the VA using ‘fake students’ in one of the largest GI Bill fraud cases ever

The owner of a technical training school in San Diego is going to prison for being, well, shady as all hell.
Paul Szoldra Avatar

The owner of a technical training school in San Diego is going to prison for being shady as hell.

On Tuesday, Blue Star Learning owner Nimesh Shah, 37, was sentenced to almost four years in jail for defrauding the Department of Veterans Affairs out of nearly $30 million in Post-9/11 GI Bill benefits, according to a news release from the Department of Justice.

Between March 2016 and June 2019, Shah “lied to the VA about the percentage of non-veteran students at the school, and made up fake non-veteran students – when in fact nearly all of their business came from veteran students,” according to the news release.

In order for Blue Star Learning to receive tuition payments from the VA for veteran students, federal regulations require at least 15 percent of people in a course to be non-veterans. But Blue Star, which charged up to $20,000 per course, “had close to 100% veteran students,” the news release said.

So what did Shah do? It was kind of like that Seinfeld episode when George tells the unemployment office that he’s very close to getting a job with ‘Vandelay Industries’ and provides Jerry’s phone number for the company, except way, way worse. Shah’s “extraordinary efforts” to deceive regulators included:

  • Providing the VA with false documents
  • Inventing fake students with fake student files, which had made-up birth dates, social security numbers, and contact information
  • Building spreadsheets with made-up employment information on ‘graduates’ (which were made up)
  • Creating 30 fictitious companies that were listed as their employers, and directing an employee to purchase 30 cell phones with voicemail greetings for each made-up company
  • Hiring people overseas to “pretend to be satisfied Blue Star Learning students” whenever they were contacted by the VA

“As laid out in court records, Shah’s scheme appears to be one of the largest Post-9/11 G.I. Bill fraud cases that has been prosecuted around the country,” the release said.

For all this effort, Shah’s company ended up with more than $11 million in tuition payments, while $18 million was paid out to veterans for housing allowances and stipends. That’s not to mention the untold number of veterans now walking around with less-than-stellar credentials from a crappy school.

“Shah knew that the vast majority of Blue Star Learning graduates did not obtain jobs in the fields in which they were purportedly receiving training, and that the employment statistics on Blue Star Learning’s website were fraudulent,” the U.S. Attorney’s Office told NBC San Diego in Nov. 2019.

Shah’s wife Nidhi, 36, who was vice president and director of education, was also sentenced to two years of probation for lying to investigators.

“This was an extraordinary fraud in terms of the elaborate deception, the years-long duration and the amount of money involved,” said U.S. Attorney Robert Brewer. “This defendant knowingly violated the rules to enrich himself, and for that he will go to prison.”

Well, bye.