7 ways James Mattis is more of a Marine than Sebastian Gorka will ever be

Author:
Updated:
Original:
AL ASAD, Iraq - Lt. Gen. James Mattis, the commander of U.S. Marine Corps Forces Central Command, speaks to the Marines of the maintenance section from Marine All-Weather Fighter Attack Squadron 121 on the Al Asad flightline, May 6, 2007. After talking to them, Mattis welcomed any questions.

Then-Lt. Gen. James Mattis, the commander of U.S. Marine Corps Forces Central Command, speaks to the Marines of the maintenance section from Marine All-Weather Fighter Attack Squadron 121 on the Al Asad flightline, May 6, 2007. 

It's been a week since former Defense Secretary James Mattis warned the American people that President Donald Trump's potential deployment of active-duty troops to quell nationwide protests would "make a mockery of the Constitution," and the president clearly can't let it go.

On Tuesday, Trump retweeted an essay authored by former White House deputy assistant to the president Sebastian Gorka that alleged Mattis was "no Marine":

Beyond the obvious hypocrisy here — the commander-in-chief never served a day in the U.S. armed forces in his life — there is another more glaring issue at play: Who the hell cares what Sebastian Gorka, who straight up acknowledges that he's "not a Marine" in his essay, has to say on the matter?

"I'm not a Marine, but I know the Marines," Gorka opens in his essay, much like the guy who "almost served" in the military.

Here's the thrust of Gorka's argument, per American Greatness:

“Mad Dog” may have worn the uniform of a leatherneck for more years than most, but he has betrayed the values of the Corps by his recent statements about the sitting commander-in-chief. He is no longer one of “the Few, the Proud,” having accused President Trump of somehow violating “the Constitutional rights of . . . fellow citizens” by walking to St. John’s Episcopal Church the day after “peaceful” protestors tried to burn the church to the ground. It’s the same church that every incoming president of the United States has stopped to pray in and show his respects on the morning of his inauguration.

Do I have a right to criticize a man like Mattis? A man allegedly called “Mad Dog” and “Chaos” by his peers? No, I never served in the U.S. military. My only military experience is a few years in the British Army reserves. Once I came to America, however, I twice took the oath of service to my new nation. Once when I joined the Defense Department as a civilian, and then again in 2017 when I joined the White House as a strategist to President Trump.

And even if none of that were true, I would still feel a duty publicly to censure Mattis for a personal reason: because of what I learned from the Marines I have worked for and with over the years. Their love of America and their respect for the truth demand that we react to such reprehensible behavior from a retired general officer who knows better.

Dr. Sebastian Gorka, Maj. Gen. Matthew C. Horner Distinguished Chair of Military Theory, Marine Corps University, speaks at the International Special Training Centre's Military Assistance Course, Pfullendorf, Germany, May 14, 2015.

Dr. Sebastian Gorka, Maj. Gen. Matthew C. Horner Distinguished Chair of Military Theory, Marine Corps University, speaks at the International Special Training Centre's Military Assistance Course, Pfullendorf, Germany, May 14, 2015.

Well, Gorka is right about one thing: He absolutely never served in the Marines and therefore should refrain from leveling any sort of assessment of Mattis' role in the organization. 

To wit, here are seven reasons Gorka should consider shutting his trap about who is and is not a Marine:

  1. Mattis commissioned as a Marine officer in 1972 through the Naval Reserve Officers' Training Corps and earned the title of Marine. Gorka did not.
  2. Mattis served for 44 years as a Marine infantry officer, commanding troops in the Persian Gulf, Afghanistan, and Iraq. Gorka never served as a Marine infantry officer, but he did serve "a few years" in the British Army reserves.
  3. During the invasion of Afghanistan, Mattis was the first Marine officer to command a Naval Task Force in combat. Gorka was not.
  4. Mattis commanded the 1st Marine Division during the invasion of Iraq. Gorka did not.
  5. Mattis once oversaw a U.S. combatant command, U.S. Central Command, as a full-blown Marine general. Gorka did not.
  6. Mattis' decorations for service in the Corps include a Bronze Star with combat 'V' device, two Defense Distinguished Service Medals, two Navy Distinguished Service Medal, the Legion of Merit, and the Combat Action Ribbon. Gorka's decorations for service in the Corps are nonexistent.
  7. Mattis' everyday carry consists of two knife hands. Gorka's everday carry is a cry for help.

The simple truth is, Gorka doesn't like Mattis' opinion — which is totally fine — and is now attacking the man's service far more than his argument. Mattis is a Marine's Marine, revered by his subordinates and superiors alike, and is a legend in the ranks. And no one, most of all Gorka, can ever take that away from him.

Though Gorka is always welcome to walk into his local recruiting office. The Marine Corps' band is always looking for another blowhard.